Clear Full Forecast

REPORT RECORDS RCMP DIVIDE

By Submitted Article

Sunday, January 25, 2009 04:09 AM

 
By  Judge wallace Craig ( Retired) 
 
PEACE OFFICERS are the bedrock of our criminal justice system.
 
Although the Criminal Code definition of a peace officer includes mayors, sheriffs, customs officers and even pilots, it truly reflects reality in only one category in which police – and police alone – are entrusted with the duty to preserve and maintain the public peace.
From coast to coast a thin blue/red line of ordinary police officers and non-commissioned officers of the RCMP and municipal police departments stands on guard for us. It is their capability to engage in physical confrontation with thugs, thieves and rowdies on a 24/7 basis that ensures us safety and security in our homes, and as we go about our communities. They keep us free.
 
“At times they are foot soldiers in a dirty and dangerous war against violence, property crime and predatory drug trafficking,” I wrote in my 2001 memoir after finishing 26 years as a judge in provincial criminal court. “(These) men and women, living and working in harsh reality, are the backbone of the criminal justice system. More than that, they are the only ones who risk injury and even death each time they go to work.”
 
Today, these frontline police officers soldier along under and in understrength detachments. With little or no prospect for promotion on merit alone, too often they are under the thumb of inept and out-of-touch white-shirted commanding officers
Since the 1950s the Royal Canadian Mounted Police has provided, under contract, rural and municipal policing in all but two provinces, in all three territories and in approximately 200 municipalities and aboriginal communities. It undertakes all of these contract duties while still attempting to do its federal duties. It is a conglomerate organization that is badly managed and requires major changes if it is to meet the public’s expectations and those of its rank and file.
 
The federal government, the Commissioner of the RCMP and the organization’s own command structure – have several reports that fully document the moribund state of the force. A year has gone by without any change since the submission of the following two reports.
The RCMP Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow: An Independent Report concerning Workplace Issues at the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, dated November 2, 2007, is a voluminous report compiled by Dr. Linda Duxbury, a professor at Carleton University in Ottawa. Duxbury’s report is a compilation of her earlier studies of management of the RCMP.
 
Duxbury updated her studies to serve as a backdrop to the report of David Brown, chairman of a federal task force enquiring into the state of the RCMP. Brown submitted his report – Rebuilding the Trust: Report of the Task Force on Governance and Cultural Change in the RCMP – to the federal minister of public safety on Dec. 14, 2007.   
 
A few weeks ago I was completely taken by surprise when I received a copy of Rebuilding Bridges: Report on Consultation of Employees and Managers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police – C Division. C Division is the Quebec division of the RCMP.
 
This report was issued Nov. 8, 2008, by researchers at the University of Montreal: Daniel Robichaud, Chantal Benoit-Barne and Joelle Basque. They were given the task of determining the causes of a management crisis in C Division.
 
Their finding, based upon extensive personal interviews with both frontline officers and commissioned officers revealed that “there was a large chasm that separates, more gravely than anticipated, (the) perspectives and realities of the members working in C-Division and its managing officers.”
They also confirmed the accuracy of the observations of the Brown task force and the findings of Dr. Linda Duxbury.
 
Rebuilding the Bridges ends with an emotionally charged note:
 
“It is time to rebuild bridges. For everyone involved in this challenge, the message of the men and women of the RCMP … is one infused with energy and a real willingness to exert the effort required. Despite all their difficult, even painful, experience, no fewer than 668 people that one might arguably label cynical and disabused found ways to circumnavigate their daily constraints to talk to us about the RCMP for hours during our visits to their sector and detachment. The RCMP is fortunate to be endowed with thousands of men and women who have its identity and mission at heart. “Here is a final telling quote from a constable: ‘If we’re frustrated, it’s because somehow we are still proud to be in the RCMP. We haven’t thrown in the towel. We want it to change because we would like to one day retire saying “maybe we made a small difference”.’
 
In 1952, British Columbia entered into its first contract with the RCMP under which E Division became our provincial police force. It began with 525 members. Today it fields at least 5000 members, a number that is increasing and will soon constitute one third of the RCMP.
We need to know if the constables and non-commissioned officers in E Division are working under conditions similar to those in C Division in Quebec. Their well-being is critical to public safety in British Columbia.
 

Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

The attitudes of today's police are instilled at depot. Those three cops that beat up that man in Vancouver, I wonder if they trained together. I also wonder if the cops today are getting much of their attitude from Hollywood.
This is a very troublesome report. I feel a lot less safe and less secure after reading it than I did before.

Looks like it's just another aspect of an ailing society that somehow got on a slippery slope to wherever.
The whole judiciary system is in disrepute here in BC, from the Judges, down to the John Wayne type sheriffs.
First, those Mounties you speak so eloquently of,(I must ask, are all you judges oblivious of what occurs around you) we must purge from BC and return back to our first line of defence law enforcers, our own Provincial Police Force. The Mounties are inherently corruptable.
Their reputations are tarnished beyond repair. People do not trust them.
Judges are far to close and cosy with the politicians in Victoria, Many BC Judges have made assine judgements--rulings in many serious criminal trials.
Why is it you guys(judges), only express your thoughts or feelings after you retire or step down? .
Is it because you lack back bone or political will?
Now, your opinions are no more credible than Joe six pack.
There is no perfect system. We all agree that police are necessary, but no matter who handles it, there will always be a segment of the population that doesn't trust them.

A very complex issue with many questions and few answers.
MrPG says, A very complex issue with many questions and few answers.

Bullsh!t that's exactly what the judiciary wishes for peons like you to think, they don't want people to question their private inner sanction and self appointed authority.
They want to remain answerable no one but themselves, just like the Mounties.
Even the legal and financial mess we are in today is due in large part to inept legal minds who have been either gorging themselves at the public trough or asleep at the switch, you can take your pick. These characters, who make and control the laws, that we must live under, are given far more credit than they deserve.
The very cops this gavel banger praises, are the one and the same who are killing, tasering, and beating innocent people and what do these guys in their robes do,nothing, they sit on their asses and do squat.
I almost forgot, all the best minds in BC have gotten together and decided they would inflict the full force of their law on a chubby guy in bountiful, who just happens to have too many girl friends. Don't go after the real bad guys, jeez they have guns and will shoot back.
Another big issue is police investigating police, that has to stop. This is a democracy, not a police state. This would help improve their credibility. Do not use retired or ex police.
furtree, thanks for proving my point.
Your welcome peon.
Name calling = what you do when you don't have a strong argument. Thanks again.
The bottom line is, our justice system is a huge goldmine for our lawyers and politicians.

So why would they change it?

The only way it will change is for the people to demand it.

Unless you see a country wide revolt, there is no use bitching about it cause they are not going to do squat about it.
"It is their capability to engage in physical confrontation with thugs, thieves and rowdies on a 24/7 basis that ensures us safety and security in our homes, and as we go about our communities."

They used to, now they stand back and tazer you.
If you're a thug, thief or rowdy, you deserve a few thousand volts.
MrPG, I would direct your attention to a couple of high profile tasering cases on persons who were not a thug, thief, or rowdy, perpetrated by our fine Mounties right here in B.C. The 84 year old man in a hospital bed in (Kelowna?) who refused to surrender his 'weapon' a small jack knife that he was waving around in his delerium, scared the three fuzz' so bad, they had to taser him, in the interest of public safety you know. You never know, he might have taken combat training just before he checked into the hospital with heart problems. Then another one in Kelowna; an elderly man who did not immediately get of his car when ordered to by the fuzz cheeked quivering cop, he got tasered too,that occurence was witnessed by the old guys' wife. However, even with that evidence, thank christ they have tasers! can you imagine how many people would be shot dead by todays breed of cops who are seemingly untrained for physical confrontation? Taser/shoot first, ask questions later. Lost has it right, the lawyers do nothing but profit from the travesty that is our justice system.
metalman.
I wasn't there and neither were you so you have no idea what the circumstance of the situation was.

I've said this before, I probably would tazer first and ask questions later rather than risk bodily injury or worse wrestling with someone not in their right mind potentially with a weapon.

These men and women have to make split second decisions, potentially life and death, often with little or no information to go on. Most of the time, they'll make the right call... it's all too easy to sit back from a safe distance and question when things don't go perfectly.
All rhetoric and ranting aside, the RCMP are our police and will continue to be in the forseeable future. I just dont see judging the whole institution by the actions (alleged in some case)of a few cops. It may feel good to portray our police force as out of control and disfunctional but the fact is that they are amoung the best in the world. They work. They also do a job most of us wouldn't. Again, people stop using your anonymity to say things about a group of people you would never say to their faces (no, not because they would taser you).
I am not defending the taser incidents described above, as i know little about them. I am saying that people are getting a little extreme in pretty much every discussion of the police. For the record, a couple of years ago i was assaulted by an old guy with a walking stick. I didnt taser him but man, he deserved a shot of something.