Clear Full Forecast

Courting Danger: Ignoring Our Bear Situation

By Michelle Cyr-Whiting

Monday, July 26, 2010 04:05 AM

                                                                                         Opinion250 file photo

Prince George, B.C. - The Wildlife Biologist with Northern Bear Awareness is wondering if it's going to take a fatality to get the City of Prince George to become a 'Bear Smart' community.

Registered Professional Biologist Lana Ciarniello says, she and the NBA have been working for years on collecting the data necessary to push the City take some concrete steps towards proactively managing the bear habitat we live within.

"There's ways to get people to do something with bears: one is someone dies and you certainly don't want that way -- you've seen it in Banff and a number of places -- where nothing's done until someone dies," she says. "And, the other, is to get a bunch of data until you force them to do it."

So that's what she's been doing. In October of 2008, Ciarniello completed a Bear Hazard Assessment for Prince George -- using a $10-thousand dollar grant and donating $10-thousand dollars worth of her time. (She says similar reports by RPBs cost approximately $20-thousand in B.C.) In October of 2009, the biologist published a Human-Bear Conflict Prevention Management Plan -- using another $10-thousand dollar grant and, again, donating half her time. (The full reports can be found at www.northernbearawareness.com) And, presently, she's conducting the Urban Bear Research project, which involves collaring bears to find out their 'critical areas' in the city.

The NBA member says, "(Collecting the data) is one of the only ways, I think, that we can start to reduce the number of bears destroyed." She says Prince George destroys the most bears annually in B.C.. The Ministry of Environment has designed a Bear Smart program that involves six criteria a community must reach to achieve bear smart status:

  1. prepare a bear hazard assessment
  2. prepare a bear/human conflict management plan that is designed to address bear hazards
  3. revise planning and decision-making documents to be consistent with bear/human conflict management plan
  4. implement a continuing education plan directed at all sectors of the community
  5. develop and maintain a bear-proof municipal solid waste management system
  6. implement 'Bear Smart' bylaws prohibiting the provision of food to bears as a result of intent, neglect or irresponsible management of attractants


So far, Kamloops is the only city with official designation, but Whistler has just completed all six.

Ciarniello says Northern Bear Awareness has done all it can to move Prince George towards that goal and, "Really, the rest falls on the City to take up."

"The City has done stuff, don't get me wrong, they've put money in, they've put bear-proof garbage cans in parks...and a number of bears were being caught and killed in Cottonwood Park and all those areas." But she says the NBA appeared before City Council three times before finally getting a resolution to move towards Bear Smart status in June of 2009.

"We (NBA) can't take it any farther," says a frustrated Ciarniello. "We can't update city planning documents, we can't make wildlife corridors and provisions for wildlife to be mandatory within new development plans, we can't finish the fencing of the Foothills landfill -- that's beyond what Northern Bear Awareness can do, we're just a group of volunteers who are concerned."


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

If all we do is prepare paperwork and documents, fence the garbage dump, etc.We might create some jobs for the people doing the studies. It will do nothing to control the bear population. We need to have open season to hunters who eat bear meat. Short and simple. If the bleeding hearts try to save all the bears, people will start getting eaten by bears. Our people are not safe in the forest anymore.
This is a no brainer. Bears are preditors, Our moose population has dropped more every year. more bears, less moose.
more bears = less moose = less bears = more moose = more bears = less moose = less bears = = =

Which of course begs the real question, we know how it works in a non-human controlled environment, nature takes care of itself.

What is the moose population we want? Why?
We don't have a bear problem in PG... just lots of bears and great habitat everywhere surrounding this city. I don't see a problem with that as long as people don't get to excited when they spot one.

Also I don't buy the bear moose argument either. Black bears are 95% herbivores and rarely eat meat unless its been killed by something else, or they are really sick and hungry on a very rare occasion. A grizzly bear however will kill a moose, but really I don't think we have a grizzly bear population problem at this time.

You are far more likely to be fatally attacked by a domestic dog, then you ever would be from a wild black bear.
I agree Eagleone.
They are just bears...we have them here.
Lots of them.
All this press about them does is get people all paranoid!
Prince George has tons of berries that attract the bears at this time of year. Saskatoons, blue berries, huckleberries, wild raspberries etc. The berries grow wild on Connaught Hill, Cottonwood, all along the river banks etc. The bears can smell them for miles. Also apple trees left with rotting apples. This is only a part of the problem.
I hate the idea of more signs, but perhaps warning the public somehow of where berries are growing so as to avoid those areas or use extra caution when walking in those areas may be a part of the solution.
And how about ensuring our garbage cans are not so easily available to them. Keep them in a shed or try not overfilling them.

A study in Alaska in the spring found that 85% of the black bears taken in their spring bear season had moose calves in the stomach.
Black bears can take a heavy toll on the young moose.
its only as good as you give.
i got interested in the bear awareness a year or so ago.
i logged on to their site but found it futile as they only updated it once a month ,if that. so in june you got to se what was happening in may etc.
Well gus have you ever seen the information that the BC gov puts out that says 10 moose poached in your area in a loss of 40 to 50 moose in 5 years.
Based on that number, how many moose do you think would be around if we shut down cow/ calf season? Limeted entry was only supposed to last 10 years, and now 30 years later here we are.
We are allways quick to blame other predators just not ourselfs.
good point doneright.

We live in bear country and that will never change. Where I live bears are seen quite often and night time is when they do most of their wandering. Yes bears are dangerous but the issue will never go away, one just adapts as in hiking.

This study will always say there is a problem, that is how research money is aquired. No problem no money.

I am not saying there will never be a bear incident the odds are for it but what about moose. There are moose incidents a few times a year, but seems to be ignored. In my personal experiance I am more wary of moose than bears.
"There's ways to get people to do something with bears: one is someone dies and you certainly don't want that way -- you've seen it in Banff and a number of places -- where nothing's done until someone dies," she says. "And, the other, is to get a bunch of data until you force them to do it."


Fear mongering and threats of force...what a novel way to try for funding??

The only way to have certainty that no one is ever killed by a black bear is to take the case of California and the grizzly bear...kill them all and nobody gets mauled.
"10 moose poached in your area in a loss of 40 to 50 moose in 5 years."

?????? Who is poaching?

What are we talking about anyway??

Bears and moose within city limits????

If the City is to blame for anything, we really cannot go outside of the City limits.

Bears and moose don't read maps. They come and go as they please. Put wildlife corridors into the city from outside the boundaries and they will come and go more often.

WE are ENCROACHING on THEIR territory.

So we either learn to live with them as they obviously learn to live with us. Will that be by leaving them alone or by controlling them?

Control them how? Killing them? Relocating them so that they can come back? Building a wildlife fence around the City?

Poaching means the same thing as hunting. The animal is dead either way. There are no additional animals born to those moose or bears. :-)

My question stands. How many bears and moose in the City is too few and how many are too many?

I'll give my opinion since no one else has done so yet.

Within the city limits - no bears and no moose.

Method of control? Combination of wildlife proofing ALL properties, INCLUDING public "wildland and park" properties, no corridors leading into city, removing animals and relocating, shooting animals within city limits, wildlife fencing at city limits or within reasonable vicinity.

To pretend we are living in harmony with nature is false. We are removing habitat from wildlife just as habitat is being removed all over the world for wild animals.

To say we are not doing the same is being hypocritical.
On that topic.

I have not seen a single moose at what used to be regular sightings on Tyner Blvd. near UNBC since they built that waterline covered with a walkway. That has been a year now. None last fall and none this spring. Encroachment of wildlife habitat and its result to me in that case.
that should read "is very clear to me in that case"
Gus... I have seen Moose a few times along that road since they finished that project ... An Immy bull I seen there last fall (I wish I had my Bow with me I woulda stalked it into the woods ...as I had a Tag in my pocket) and this year there is at least one cow and calf as I have seen the pair twice but cant tell if they are the same pair. I have seen several differant ones at FFTW along with a couple of bear ... there was one color phase blacky and one blonde for sure ...

last week I had an encounter with a small blackie at wilkins park in Miworth Friday eve. 200 yards from the picnic area ... I spooked it off to the woods away from the area as there were many young familys at the picnic area.

Eagleone ... I see that 97.8% of your statistics are completly made up numbers.... Bears are Omnivores just like humans but typically they are lazy and will eat whatever is easist for them "harvest" more often than not when they crave meat they will take a young calf whether it be a moose, elk, domestic cattle, Fox pups etc.......
Bears eat alot of meat I dont know the typical ratio but I assure you its more than 5% of their diet ... Its closer to 100% near the fall as they prepare to hibernate .. as flora doesnt provide the fat needed for them to survive the winters nap.
Although bears are classified in the carnivore family, they exhibit characteristics that are predominately ominivoristic. 85% of their diet is typically vegetable matter. They also eat seeds, insects, berries, nuts, and some meat including carrion. Black bears also develop a taste for human garbage.
"Our people are not safe in the forest anymore" ???? Were we ever? By definition the outdoors is a risky place, we just have to be more aware of the impact we have on the residents of said forests.
As for moose on Tyner Blvd., tell the group of joggers that were chased a few weeks ago that there are no moose there.
I bike up there fairly regularly & have seen a few moose, a couple of bears & 2
deer in the same place almost every ride.
Prince George has been here for approx 100 years. The bear problem is worse now than it has ever been. At one time bears would be hanging around the Garbage dump, (Which is now the High School along the by pass) however as a general rule if they came onto someones property rural or City they were usually shot on the spot. This of course kept their numbers down, and also kept them wary of people.

Fast forward to 2010 and the situation is very different. Less hunters, less people with guns since the Gun Registry, people now phone to Game Wardens however they can only do so much.

So we now have a situation where bears wander through town upsetting garbage cans, and generally being a pain in the butt.

People who have not been here very long. The newcomers of the last 20/30 years actually think that bears have always been in the City. I can tell you that they were never tolerated in the old days. They were shot. Period.

The City has grown outward in some areas, especially College Heights, and the Hart Highway, and therefore infringes on their territory, however there is hundreds of thousands of square miles out there for bears. There is no reason what so ever for them being in town routing around the garbage other that is is easy food.,

I say chase them back into the wilderness and in the long run you will be doing them a favour. Leaving them as scavengers in the City is not a solution.

PS. Bears are scavengers, and they stink to high heaven. There is a huge difference between a real bear, and the pretty pictures you see in the papers.


I think its cheap that this website would try to jingle the collection jar for yet another "starving" biologist. This system of "Do a study and say what we want to hear and you get money" is exactly what decimated our wild animal populations and continues to wreak havoc on our ecosystems. This particular biologist is obviously not doing a study on what the upper echelons of the wildlife management community deem "study worthy" so she starves. Next year she'll know better and do a study on bears being affected by climate change and roll in the dough. And lose yet another bright young mind to to the same people who enjoyed government-sponsored holidays in the backcountry closed to everyone but themselves while they slaughtered countless animals in one failed study after another.
Honey garlic bear pepperoni....Yum, eh Bowzone?
Of course the local garbage bears don't make for good pepperoni. The wilderness ones are the ones you want for meat.
Palopu is right--chase them back to the wilderness with GUNS. They understand that and will stay away. After we practice that for 4 years there will only be one bear sighting in the city every year. Do the same with the moose. I'm sorry to have to inform the animal rights people, but animals are just that and we are humans. We have the power and we use it to go where we want to. The animals were put here for us to use as we see fit and if we have to run them off, then we should.
Unlike a grizzly bear a black bear doesn't have the flesh cutting cheek teeth of other predators nor do they have the grinding molars and efficient stomachs of herbivores. That's why black bears need to eat a lot of food to get the nutrition they require and why they eat mostly pre-killed tender meat that has been dead for a while and the most tender parts of a plant.

Although a black bear can run in short distances as fast as 35 miles per hour they however have a problem of five toes each with non retractable claws and so they walk heal to toe making the ability to chase other animals for a kill very difficult as they are not designed for that and its therefor not in their nature. Predators all walk on their toes. Only humans and bears walk from heal to toe.

In the spring bears will eat winter kill moose that have died from the elements and even emerge from their dens early if there is some nearby... a bear can smell a dead animal from more than 8km away and after a harsh winter there is a lot of dead moose to scavenge off the ground once they go looking. A black bear will never kill a moose on its own though much less any other animal.

Bears have the largest brain of any mammal other than a human and are smarter than the smartest of dogs, and by some accounts have shown signs of being able to reason there way through a situation unlike almost any other animal.

Black bears are the ultimate survivors and will be around long after humans have long since disappeared.