The Ascension of Christy Clark - Part 1 -Change
By Peter Ewart
Monday, February 28, 2011 03:44 AM
By Peter Ewart
In her campaign for the BC Liberal leadership, Christy Clark has repeated a number of buzzwords many times in her speeches and comments. Prominent ones include "change", "family", "rural" and "coalition". Why has she chosen these words to highlight her campaign and what is their significance? As she will soon take her position as the new Premier of British Columbia, some further analysis is warranted.
Let us start with the word "change" which is incessantly repeated in all her presentations. Here are just a few of the phrases in which she uses it: "Change is coming to this province ...", "Time for a change ...", "Partnership for change ...", "Countdown to change ...", "BC needs change ...", "BCers are very, very hungry for change ...", and so on.
Why has Christy Clark been using this particular word so frequently? Part of the answer lies in the structure of the political process in the province and the fact that, in its current form, it is becoming dysfunctional for the globalized big business elite that dominates it, as well as mistrusted by the people of the province.
Traditionally, the political process in the province has operated on the "black horse / white horse" principle. What this means is that the political and big business elite install a "black horse" political party for a number of years until it becomes discredited in the eyes of the people. Then it is time to bring in the "white horse" which is presented as a significant "change" from the previous horse, and thus helps placate the voters discontent. The beauty of this system is that no matter which colour it is, the horse is always tethered to the agenda of big business, and any "wild horses" with another agenda are kept out.
But a problem has arisen - the system has broken down. The BC Liberals under Gordon Campbell (the "black horse") fell into abject disrepute over a number of issues, including the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST), the BC Rail scandal, cabinet minister defections, and a host of other ills. The time was ripe for the "white horse", i.e. the Carole James-led NDP, to come galloping forward as the "change" and the "alternative" to the lamed and discredited BC Liberals. Indeed, James had spent a great deal of time and effort courting big business in the province and allaying any of its fears. The idea was that she and her party could bring "change" that would calm down the electorate (which had become increasingly feisty especially after the successful HST citizens' petition), yet still not threaten the agenda of big business in any serious way.
But such was not to happen. The dysfunctionality of the current party-dominated (and autocratic) political system had afflicted the NDP itself. Last Fall, the party almost tore itself apart in a bitter factional fight, the final outcome of which was the resignation of Carole James herself. So now, not only was the "black horse" lame and discredited, but the "white horse" was also.
This has thrown the big business elite in this province into a quandary. How could it keep its agenda in place while at the same time defusing the growing discontent of the BC populace? What could be the solution?
Enter Christy Clark, backed by long time political operative Patrick Kinsella and a faction within the BC Liberal Party. If the "black horse / white horse" system had broken down, i.e. the NDP was not in a position to come forward as the "white horse" to save the day, then why not create a "white horse" within the BC Liberal Party itself that would at least give the illusion of change?
And so, over the last several months, we have witnessed Christy Clark's campaign of "change", and now she, like Lady Godiva on her white horse, has been chosen to trot around the ridings of the province as the new premier and convene the dozen rural town-hall sessions she has promised in her first year of office.
Can Clark and her faction pull it off? It's an easy thing to rent a "white horse" and gallop around the province shouting "change". It's a much harder thing to line up the other unhappy factions of the BC Liberal Party behind her steed, let alone the increasingly discontent and disaffected people of the province.
And, of course, there will still be the NDP's version of the "white horse" for Clark to cope with later in the Spring, along with some new, increasingly appealing, "wild horses" in the form of independents and small parties.
One thing for sure - it will not be an easy ride.
Stay tuned for Part 2 of "The Ascension of Christy Clark".
Peter Ewart is a columnist and writer, based in Prince George, British Columbia. He can be reached at: peter.ewart@shaw.ca
Previous Story - Next Story
Return to Home
Cheers