Clear Full Forecast

Olympic Dreams, Forest Industry Reality

By Peter Ewart

Saturday, October 14, 2006 03:51 AM

       

What should be the main focus of the provincial government during this particular period of history? Clearly the decision has already been made: it has chosen the 2010 Olympics. And its not hard to see why. Just imagine the Olympics with its dazzling stadiums, soaring buildings of concrete and glass, and brand new subway line. Countless television interviews. Flashing cameras. Celebrities. Movie stars. Visiting dignitaries. Sleek limousines. A politicians’s wildest dream fulfilled – to be at centre stage in front of the entire world for two whole weeks.

But something else in the shadows is demanding attention. BC’s forest industry is not glamorous. It’s hard hatted workers carrying lunchpails, snorting logging trucks roaring down backroads, whining saws and smelly pulpmills. It’s falling trees in minus 30 degree temperatures or planting them in the heat of summer surrounded by swarms of mosquitoes. It’s 90,000 direct jobs and hundreds of thousands of indirect jobs. It’s little towns and villages like Burns Lake, Fort St. James, Houston and Mackenzie, and bigger ones like Quesnel, Prince George and Kamloops.

Not a movie star, celebrity or foreign dignitary anywhere in sight.

One thing is for sure – the forest industry is definitely not the Olympics. It is something else entirely - the bread and butter of the BC economy and has been so for the last 100 years. Indeed, our region is a world centre for forestry production. But this industry is descending into a crisis that could end up in a permanent decline of forest manufacturing in this province.

Inflammatory words? Hardly. Listen to what Jock Finlayson, executive vice-president of the BC Business Council, has to say: "We’ve got this so-called boom going on in the BC economy yet the largest industry here is not booming …. It’s facing some very, very tough business conditions" (Vancouver Sun, Sept. 23, 2006). Indeed, the pine beetle problem in the BC Interior has been described as the biggest natural disaster of its kind in recorded North American history.

But besides the pine beetle, the forest industry in BC is facing a host of other problems, ranging from the tariffs imposed under the new softwood lumber agreement, global competition, the plunging U.S. housing market, and so on. Other parts of Canada are facing similar problems with mill closures in Saskatchewan, Northern Ontario, and most recently, Quebec.

Yet there are those politicians and government officials who still persist in believing that everything will be fine, even with a greatly diminished forest sector. Mesmerized by visions of the 2010 Olympics, and dreams of pipelines, gas wells, and call centers that they believe are just over the horizon, they boast that things have never been better. And after all, why focus on the negative? Think positive.

Some economic development people will even tell you that they are not interested in talking about forest industry diversification in itself, but only economic diversification in general.

This is a dangerous attitude. Forestry is the backbone of the provincial economy. Without this backbone, what will we have? A de-industrialized economy, one with the spine of a jellyfish.

Forestry manufacturing gives value, breadth and depth to the provincial economy like no other industry. But it is not getting the attention it deserves from all levels of government.

For example, in regards to the funds earmarked for the pine beetle problem, the federal government has promised $100 million a year over the next 10 years. Given the magnitude of this problem that amount will clearly not be enough. But it dwarfs the provincial government’s contribution (much of which has come out of the sale of BC Rail and from federal funding).

There is some irony here because for many years the provincial government has been the recipient of tens of billions of dollars in stumpage revenue, royalties and taxes from the Interior and North. Yet the Victoria government has so far not even matched the federal contribution, which in itself will not be adequate.

Is there a message here? Could it be that, despite all its talk, the government in Victoria is writing off the Interior and North and its pine beetled forests?

Perhaps that explains why some people are subtly trying to change the tone and nature of the discussion. When they talk about how we are now in "a post-beetle stage", are these really code words for "a post forest industry stage"? They act as if they have already thrown in the towel on the forest industry, and instead focus on oil and gas, call centers, tourism, and, yes, the Olympics, but have little or nothing to say about taking the wood manufacturing of the Interior to the next step: secondary and tertiary manufacturing, and getting more value out of the wood.

Yes, the pine beetle will take a big bite out of the forest, but there are still many healthy trees of other species out there, as well as the standing dead pine. We could and should become a world leader on how to utilize and sustain forests in the midst of radical climate change. And on how to preserve forestry-based communities. Both the provincial and federal governments can play an important role in this, but it means being clear on priorities.

To have a wood manufacturing industry on the scale that exists in the Interior and North of BC is an asset that far overshadows all the fleeting dazzle of any Olympics. It is a jewel that any other part of the world would give their eye teeth for.

The Olympics lasts for two weeks; the forest industry has lasted for a hundred years. Will we allow it to be greatly diminished across the region or even extinguished in some communities? Or will we demand that the provincial and federal governments put this problem front and centre where it should be?

We need to deepen and expand wood manufacturing in this region and take it to a new level of more intensive and sustainable use, not abandon it. And we, as a region, need to make that point very clear to Victoria and Ottawa.

No one else will.


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

>"...but there are still many healthy trees of other species out there, as well as the standing dead pine."<

Fortunately.

>"Indeed, the pine beetle problem in the BC Interior has been described as the biggest natural disaster of its kind in recorded North American history."

I think it is more man-made than natural. The burning of trillions of tons of fossil fuels during the last 100 years had to have some consequence eventually - and it is called Global Warming.

1800 of the world's most eminent scientists, including Nobel laureates, crafted and sent a letter to President Bush, expressing the urgent need to deal world-wide with the effects of man-made global warming by reducing emissions immediately - no reply, apparently.

Bush, Howard and Harper have yet to sign on to Kyoto. Most of the rest of the world already has.

Pity.

I believe that we are shamefully shortsighted when it comes to sustainability; there will be no such thing as twilight-years in the forest industry if we begin now to explore the potential for new products and new markets. The forest and all resources must be treated as renewable and sustainable meaning we need dedicate ourselves to'farming'or 'gardening' not extracting. Our resources can no longer be considered 'staples; they are integral to our future. We will never be far from 'hewers of wood and drawers of water'; that is our blessing, our natural economic advantage, our raison d'etre. Sustainability is about creating a community heart and pulse - building from within. "The environment is not a gift from our ancestors, but a loan from our children."
We reap what we sow

The forest industry is dying in British Columbia and good riddance to it. The forests have been devastated by the forest industry and chainsaws, bulldozers and logging trucks have scarred and polluted the land from Washington to Alaska. We don't need to expand this industry, we need to destroy it.

The Pine Beetle is here because hominid apes like us lack any sense of ecologically responsibility.

I have no sympathy for loggers. For two centuries these hominid bipedal termites have been eating away at the trees, destroying the most magnificent, and laying waste to the habitat of hundreds of species where the forest is a home and not a source of toilet paper and cedar decks.

When I look out over the obscenity of a clear-cut I feel an overwhelming sadness and a seething anger at the greed and excess of human society.

I spent 6 months in the sixties planting trees and feeling like I was posing as a Johnny Douglas Fir cone, dropping seedlings into the ground. I knew I was wasting my time when we planted 10,000 dead trees one day. I remember commenting to the crew boss that the trees were dead and he answered that we were "paid to plant the bastards and nothing in the contract says they have to be alive." When I reported this I was fired.

Instead of planting trees I found more job satisfaction in spiking trees although the health and salary benefits were not so good.

I feel a great sense of satisfaction when I see those areas of the forests that I helped to spike in the eighties like the south slope of Grouse mountain or Meares Island. We inoculated those trees from the hominid borne disease called clear-cut logging.

In less than two centuries humans have transformed and diminished the land. Vancouver Island was once known as Comox or the land of plenty. Now the salmon have been decimated, the wolves and bears eradicated, the aboriginal cultures smashed and trivialized - what a frigging piece of work is man, how ignoble in reason. how infinite in greedy faculties, the paragon of anthropocentric conceit, the most destructive of animals.

The Olympics are also a joke - a jingoistic competition to see which nation has the fastest, strongest, dumbest specimens. These people spent most of their young life training and suffering to perform in a two week circus and then 99% of them are forgotten while the 1% goes on to sell Wheaties or yoghurt.

And is this what life is about? The effort of years of training for the sole purpose of shaving 1/10 of a second off the record of some uber person from before. As the Earth burns, people run, swim, jump, dive, ski, and do backflips and figure eights on ice so they can stand on a podium and proudly watch a piece of rag hoisted over their head. What does the geographical location of a person's birth have to do with their ability to pole vault or slide down an ice chute steering a sled with their ass cheeks?

The bottom line is there are to many people and the world's 6.8 billion humans are out of control. More people, more houses, more cars, less trees, less fish, less water, less clean air.

Men need to keep it in their pants and women need to close their legs and we all have to stop popping out the bambinos on the naked ape assembly line.

We have built economic and social systems that are dependent upon unlimited growth. Humans are so damn common now that no one blinks or gives a thought when a plane goes down and snuffs a few hundred. And how many people have been killed in Iraq? Lancet says 650,000 while Bush says that only a mere 30,000 have died? I guess were supposed to feel good with a "mere" 30,000 deaths and what the hell are they anyway, just faceless numbers. We don't know them and even if a few of us may have known one or two American soldiers who died fighting for "freedom" we have the consolation that they died as heroes. Hell anyone who gets their nuts blown off or loses a fingernail in this ridiculous war is called a hero although we are not allowed to see their flag draped coffin unloaded back home in the land of the once free and the home of the pathetically brain dead.

But back to the forest industry. I hope the B.C. forest industry strangles in it's own corruption and greed and chokes on the water it has polluted. This industry has controlled the economy, the politics and the media in British Columbia ever since Mr. Lover of the Universe governed the land over a century ago. We no longer have forests, we have managed rows of renewable product. A forest was designed to be a home to millions of non-hominid Earthlings, it was not designed to be made into homes for one species of Earthling.

Human beings, the great conceited naked ape who has become a divine fantasy in our own minds, the be all and end all, the supreme product of evolution, or so we like to think. From Homo erectus to Homo arrogantus, a species to deviously clever for our own good, lacking memory and devoid of the ability to envision the future, living in the now, wanting it all now and justifying it all with silly pie-in-the-sky fantasies of flying monkeys, pustulating prophets, murky messiahs, and megalomaniacal Gods made in the image of their creators.

We are a species that continually spurts out babies so we can kill them in wars, a species that wipes out the fish and blames the seals, a species that fouls the air, the water and the land with poisons and freaks out when some Congressman sends an e-mail to a page. Yes, a species whose priorities are so screwed up we will pay millions for a photograph of Tom Cruise's kid instead of helping to feed a HIV infected toddler in Africa. A species obsessed with instant gratification and constant entertainment.

We are frigging insane and our insanity is so advanced we think it is normal. Two hundred million people have been slaughtered, tortured, raped and mutilated by us normal people in the last century alone. But hey, we defeated Hitler and now we have George W(hat an asshole) Bush.

That pseudo Texan shrub alone is proof positive that Americans have gone off the deep end and Harper is proof positive that the Loonie is a fit name for the loons that spend it.

Okay already. My rant is over for now or at least until someone else send me another right wing wacko story like the one below.

- Paul Watson




Well said Paul however I suggest that your comments will not be seen, by most people, and misunderstood by many who read them. The action in this country is at a donut and coffee shop, shopping mall, hockey game, or gambling casino. All ventures that will enhance the mind and mend the body.

Show me a Politician that cares about People, the enviroment, etc; and is willing to say and do the tough things that need to be done to save this Country from itself, and I will show you a politician that cannot get elected.

Eat potatoe chips, and hot dogs, drink pop and beer, put on 40 pounds, break wind, and have a good life. That seems to cover it.
Most of what Paul Watson says is so, but for one thing: his admission that he spiked trees. That is a criminal act, bad enough but understandable if it harms no one. However, spiking trees puts fallers lives in danger and makes him no different than the people he condemns. Its something to be ashamed of, not to brag about.
Paul be careful about Amour de Cosmos he was one of BC's true patriots.

One of BC�s founding fathers Amour de Cosmos who in the 1870 fixed legislative debate on confederation said, �I would not object to a little revolution now and again in British Columbia after Confederation if we were treated unfairly.� lol

One of many great quotes from a great character and patriot to BC, commonly known as Mr 'Lover of the Unverse'.
Terrific read, Mr. Watson! We all know how we got to this stage of human evolution, it is all history now and none of it can be undone.

The question is: How will we do things differently in the future? Or will we? Look at the politicians that are running our country and the equally idea-less opposition parties! It doesn't look very promising - they are all lining up at the trough, pretending to support either the right wing or the left wing agenda.

The ultimate emasculation of Canada is yet to come, shortly: the integration of Canada and Mexico into the United States of America, European Union style. That is when the plunder of the last Canadian resources will really begin in earnest - you ain't seen nothing yet! We will all have the same currency, which means that Canadians and Mexicans (Mexico and Canada have huge oil reserves) will be ordered to step up to the till and help pay off the huge war debts that have been piled up by the man from the Lone Star state!
from Lefty's post: "How would the local economy fare if one pulp mill and 4-5 local sawmills closed their operations?"

We will find out.

Interestingly, it can also be "modelled" right now from a socio-economic point of view.
This comment was e-mailed to us for inclusion:

"I would like to say a few words to Paul Watson. First of all, I am sure he gets some of his �donations� or whatever he lives on from these same people that he claims �devastated� the province. The only reason everything is being cut down at this time is because the tree huggers convinced the government to leave the trees in Tweedsmuir Park, thereby giving the pine beetle a stranglehold on the pine forests he so dearly loves.


I would also like to know if he eats meat or fish as well, or does he live off berries and wild vegetables. Does he grow his own garden? Mr. Watson seems to want to put the blame on anyone but himself for all the woes of the world. Has he ever had a real job where he pays taxes or are the rest of us supporting him as well? Does he have any children that we support as well?


It makes me extremely mad when I look at the amount of taxes I pay each year for the whole country to have a better way of life, and someone like this comes along and basically says that each of us that have a job that is in the forest industry or depends on it are all fools.

Thank you.

Duffer