Clear Full Forecast

Stepping Up The Land Claims: One Man's Opinion

By Ben Meisner

Thursday, December 07, 2006 03:45 AM

    
Last Week the Auditor General said that we have got to speed up the land claims settlements in BC. We have spent hundreds of millions of dollars but have not had any claims settled.
When Oh When will we finally have the courage to do the proper thing and settle them in one final swoop.

The settlement is so simply as to be silly.

The problem however is that the negotiators, the lawyers, the chiefs, and indeed the government don’t want to address it.


Call every single person with a land claim in, have them sign on the bottom line for what ever figure you choose , say one million dollars over 20 years. Every single native receives that money and then signs off any further claims against BC, Canada or whoever.

They become like us, just ordinary Canadians.

$1 million dollars to compensate for any previous damages.

You can’t do it this way you say, the average Canadian native doesn’t know how to look after the money.  Who says, the chiefs of the tribe?  The  government, or the negotiators? If we continue to treat these people like they must be looked after because they can’t do it for themselves, nothing will change .

Of course there will be those who will fall through the cracks with that kind of money, you don’t need to look any further then the rank ands file of society to see where that happens every day.

It gives the people who after all are the providers of the purse, some finality to the matter.


No need for special rights negotiations, no need for any of the special housing or special areas set aside. The average family of four would have, four million dollars, surely enough to do, or acquire anything they might want in life. If they want a special area a few families can get together and buy it.


Now I know it sounds pretty simple, but who says it won’t work?  Until we finally get our heads screwed on right in the matter, it will be another 100 years before the land claims are settled.

I’m Meisner and that’s one man’s opinion.   


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

I think that they would then cry that they got once taken advantage of by the cruel and vicous white man as they were caught at a weak moment and want it redone again and again and again...

Maybe some of them would like to take responsibility for things done to my ancestors.
Good idea Ben. Now how do you get it to happen?
Your proposal ignores the fact that Native Nations refuse to sign any treaties that have finality, i.e. which can not be re-opened later for renewed demands and re-negotiation.

Since they are equal partners in any treaty negotiations their desires and ambitions must be respected.

To the best of my knowledge the Nisgaa treaty for instance is not a final settlement but has clauses in it that allow it to be re-visited in the future if certain conditions change.

Also, why would they choose to become ordinary Canadians just like us when they are already enjoying many special considerations that set them apart?
Ben I think you are right if the negotiators would let the individuals decide this deal would be done and thier would be a lot of happy natives/Canadians.I feel that the way it is going now the individual native will end up with very little and the negotioators will get the lions share of whats to come now and down the road.
Let's face it, the lawyers, the hired negotiators and the accountants will be receiving the bulk of any settlements.

The rest will be scooped by the check cashing shops and the car dealers. Within a year or two, it will all be gone and we will still have a population who will still be relying on our welfare system to take care of them.

I agree with Ben, if it was possible to get it done with and we can all move on. But I don't really think that is the solution for the future of the natives. This is a generational problem than won't be solved with money. Chester