Clear Full Forecast

Airing Concerns About Economic Diversification

By 250 News

Thursday, October 18, 2007 04:00 AM

Prince George, B.C. - So, the question is, as  Prince George tries to diversify the economy in the shadow of the mountain pine beetle, does it do so at the cost of the environment, at the cost of air quality?   That is the question  the Alternatives and Opportunities, forum looked to answer. 

It was the first of a four part series of discussions about the  future  for Prince George and how that future will be shaped by the major issues facing the community.   The issues being:  air quality,  labour stability, technology and crime.

(at right,  about 20 people  turned out to the Two Rivers Art Gallery to  hear the comments from  three  very different speakers)

Bruce Sutherland, the owner of a successful company which has diversified it's customer base; Councilor Don Zurowski who has  been on the City Council  throughout the beetle epidemic and  air quality issues;   and Dave Fuller, the President of PACHA, the People's Action Committee for Healthy Air.

There is concern any growth or diversification of the city would have an impact on the quality of the air as the airshed in Prince George has already been declared “fragile”.

Bruce Sutherland, the President of Wolftek Industries and Chair of the Northern Trust says  with 40 employees,  his company has diversified .  It started out serving just the forestry industry, but has since grown to service other industries, including mining. Diversification, is the key says Sutherland when it comes to any aspect of economic planning.  Sutherland says the mountain pine beetle crisis has  created a situation  for partnerships and research “See the problem, seek an answer, create a solution”.

Councilor Don Zurowski  was the second panelist  to speak and  noted  air quality is on the Provincial agenda, and on the Federal agenda.  The real problem for Prince George says Zurowski, comes in the Pm2.5 levels.  “Even if there was no industry we live at the confluence of two rivers, with cutbanks and dust, and it is difficult” says Zurowski.  Still, he says  the city is doing what it can to see that new industry is not located in the bowl area.   “We must challenge permit issuers to monitor and enforce the regulations.  We must be more vocal with the regulators”    He also wants to make sure permits are checked regularly and “enforced with major fines and consequences.”

Zurowski says changes have been made but there needs to be more, because air quality is a major factor when people are making a choice about moving here.  “We have to work with the existing permit holders.”  Zurowski says “We are working with major industry who have invested lots of money and were permitted, and now we want to change the rules in the middle of the game.  We have to offer some incentive.”  He says  there  should be tax breaks for those who invest in change, and penalties for  those who don't.

The President of PACHA, (the People’s Action Committee for Healthy Air) Dave Fuller says despite the fact the issue has been on the radar for the City for more than a decade, the air is getting worse.  He says there are too many studies, not enough action.    As for solutions:  Fuller suggests that in Europe, effluent ponds at pulp mills have to be covered, those ponds are the source of much of the sulphur smell.  He says the odour factor this week has been five times the “acceptable” limits. “If that were you or I the City or Regional District would act.”

He says there are other things like a ring road, to reduce  heavy emissions from traffic,  regular reviews of permits and stiffer penalties for polluters “Through collaboration we can make Prince George a better place for all of us.”


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

"Still, he says the city is doing what it can to see that new industry is not located in the bowl area."

I see. Deos not seem that is done in practice.

If the City were really practicing by those words, the City would cooperate better with the MoE with a City requirement that when a new plant is applying for a building permit they ensure an assessment is first done on the impact of that plant, including its impact on the air. Once that is done and is acceptable, then both permits can be issued.
"now we want to change the rules in the middle of the game"

Woa!!!!! .. the game has been going on ever since the Pulp mills were built and other mills were built some 40 years ago. Does he really think the game has not changed in the middle of the game. The game has changed in the middle of a whole number of games. Searches boarding an aircraft, not taking a drink on board, bicycle helmets, seat belts, secure caps on wells, catalytic converters, unleaded gasoline .......

I think we could each list at least 100 specific instances where businesses and individuals operate today under considerably more restrictive practices than they did 40 years ago. Just because someone has lived for as long as that, or has operated a business for as long as that, does not mean that they do not need to comply with new laws. The only consideration which is typically given is the length of time one has to comply to new conditions.

The shut down of beehive burners is a case in point specific to air quality. There are still some around, but the requirement to shut them down, which is now over 10 years old has required industry to make changes.
"He says there are too many studies, not enough action."

Ain't that the truth! It is a continuing project at UNBC. This shouldn't be someone's pet pure science project. We need someone who is an accountable professional who will apply the known science in order to effect change. And we need a government that is committed to make meaningful change in an air shed everyone has accepted as being in need of being cleaned up for the sake of the people living here and for the sake of the economic viability of this city.
“Through collaboration we can make Prince George a better place for all of us.”

There has been collaboration through a joint committee on air quality for 10 or so years. It is not collaboration which is missing, it is the willingness and authority to act that is missing. Its basically no more than a tea party.
Overall impressions of the meeting the way it was reported?? ..... couched words, no leaders emerging that are ready to get on with it.
I agree Owl - just more plastic band aids covering the problem.
The real problem for Prince George says Zurowski, comes in the Pm2.5 levels. “Even if there was no industry we live at the confluence of two rivers, with cutbanks and dust, and it is difficult” says Zurowski.

Don't eat that Elmer its horse sh..t. I guess he thinks we all mushrooms, kept in the dark and fed manure.

Cheers
As long as nobody dares to oppose the mayor's so-called futuristic plan to put a beetle wood burning plant in the downtown to produce steam for heating buildings there I do not have much faith in the sincerity of any of the groups that proclaim concern about the air we breathe.

That plant belongs somewhere far away from the bowl. It can produce steam for electric power generation - BC Hydro will buy the power.

Is Zurowski aware of this issue?

Is anybody going to shoot down the mayor's idea before it gets legs?



It is not just a city issue. The fed's and province pay for health care, and are responsible for our highway infrastructure that connects our industrial parks.

The solution is a ring road to move the goods, connected to industrial parks outside the city airshed, and enforced by the environment ministries. The city is responsible for conveying these concerns to the federal and provincial government so the funds can be made avaiable for the capital works projects required to make this happen.

All local politicians fail the voters of this region in this regard.
Right on Chadermando
"The solution is a ring road to move the goods, connected to industrial parks outside the city airshed, and enforced by the environment ministries. The city is responsible for conveying these concerns to the federal and provincial government so the funds can be made avaiable for the capital works projects required to make this happen.

All local politicians fail the voters of this region in this regard."

We should get going before the next election and endorse those candidates who support this concept.
Zurowski says: "Even if there was no industry we live at the confluence of two rivers, with cutbanks and dust..."

With all due respect, Mr. Zurowski, dust doesn't smell and taste like sulphur, and doesn't burn your nose, mouth and lungs.

Weren't you in town on Monday? That wasn't the taste of dust, and it had nothing to do with the size of particals. It's the chemicals in the air, too, but we seem to always get stuck on the size of the particals.
Sure hope the tourists don't take advantage of the ring roads. Could happen.
I spent some time in Kamloops last summer where the city lies between large hills and at the confluence of two rivers. Not many air quality issues there. Whats missing? Oh yeah...heavy industry...the main reason for our poor air quality.
It's an absolute joke.

Our so called "leaders" are so paranoid of insulting multi-million dollar corporations, that they have to resort to ridiculous claims like the air quality is equally impacted by idling cars, sand from the cutbanks, backyard wiener roasts and industrial emissions.

Give it up already, I'm sick of it. When will our "leaders" accept the reality that "the smell of money" is also the "smell of disease and death"? When will they see that it's also the "smell of a City that doesn't have the willingness to deal with issues"? When will they clue in that it's also the "smell of a City that doesn't know how to grow and develop"? When will they realize that it's also "the smell of a place that people will not want to live and invest in"?

The "leadership" on this issue has been downright PATHETIC and no excuse submitted to date as to why it hasn't been addressed is acceptable. The people with the power to do something about the problem have fallen flat on their faces. It's shameful.

Oh and "big business" can spare me the sob story. We've had to breathe their crap for decades. I think a little payback in the form of a clean environment is long overdue.
Well said NMG!
I happened to be admiring that aerial picture of PG upstairs in the public library and was thinking how little the town used to be.
Then along came industry and jobs, and then the town got big.

People should not have built in the valley. Industry got there first.
This time the chicken came before the egg. It isn't going to get much better. Move out of the toilet bowl.