Clear Full Forecast

West Meets East -- by Trevor Metz

By 250 News

Monday, May 23, 2005 09:05 AM


Trevor Metz on left, with friend on great wall of China

I desperately wanted to write about the recent BC election but I figure that really isn’t fair. I am a political junky and I followed the issues and the controversies as much as possible from here but I feel like I am just not qualified to publish an educated opinion, so I am going to refrain. As painful as that is to me, I am going to keep my opinions to myself on that issue and talk about something I know a little more intimately.

One of the first things that struck me as odd when I arrived in China was that all the buildings were so poorly built. I am not talking about some mud shanty in the middle of some rice paddy, but brand spanking new high rise construction. I love my apartment because it affords me a gorgeous view of the downtown eastside of Beijing, but I absolutely hate the way it is built. My shower leaks, there iare small cracks in the plaster on the walls, and the baseboards are all cracked and don’t quite fit right. You don’t notice these things when you first walk in, but if you sit there for a while, like I have, the imperfections start jumping out at you. The point I am trying to make is that not only should we be shipping raw materials to China’s exploding housing market, but we should be trying to export our building know how.


Leaky condos have nothing on China. It’s a well known fact that if you don’t watch your contractor and workmen with hawk eyes they will give you shoddy work and use inferior materials. I have had the opportunity to watch Chinese construction in action recently. I used to have a view out both my massive picture window and a side window but right after I moved in they started building a new apartment beside me. The workers start at seven in the morning and quit at seven at night but that isn’t what bothers me. I can’t help but look on in amazement at how crappy their building techniques are. I watched with a gaping mouth as the workers build a wall using bricks and mortar then smashed half of it down to install a beam, then build the wall around it again. It was insane. There are massive gaps around the beam and it doesn’t appear to be sitting flush on top of the bricks. This is common in China. I really shudder at the thought of an earthquake since I live on the 30th floor.


The problem as I see it in bringing over skilled workers and materials is two fold. First of all the Chinese are still very protectionist when it comes to labour. I think you would have to get foreign experts approval and employ huge quantities of Chinese workers. Labour is dirt cheap here so that isn’t a problem, the problem is training. Secondly, Building materials like bricks and mortar are so cheap over here that I doubt many people would even consider using wood because they have to pay international commodity prices. It’s the same reason I am not sure Pacific Western Brewers could sell their beer here.Chinese beer is bad. In fact it’s really bad. But I drink it happily because I pay about 35 cents a can for it in the grocery store. In the price to taste ratio it just makes good sense. Unless PWB markets itself as an exclusive and premium bottle of suds or begins to take advantage of cheap labour by opening a brewery here then I think they will have a hard time breaking into the market.


China is being seen as the land of milk and honey by the rest of the world, and truth be told, I am guilty of dreams of grandeur and self delusion as well. It will take a lot more that just opening shop in Beijing to be successful. BC wood and other products will have to become more affordable or the average income of the average Chinese person is going to have to rise dramatically before they can afford it. While the economic fortunes of the average person are getting better over here, there is still a long, long way to go. I’m not saying we shouldn’t try, I’m just saying as great as the economy is over here, it’s not going to be easy.

-Trevor Metz is a transplanted B.C. Journalist, who is currently working in Beijing


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

It is a pity that you didn't write about our recent provincial election. I for one would have been interested to see what it looked like to someone outside the country.
We should teach China how to build?

Maybe we should first show that we can construct something as simple as paved roads which do not deteriorate into potholes at the junction of strips of paving. Or how about road markings which do not fade within mere months? Or high rise apartments which do no leak?

Let quality Canadian companies such as Bombardier help the Chinese with their aero and rail industry.

In the meantime, let the Europeans who can make windows and doors which last, build impeccable kitchen cabinets as well as kitchen appliances and bathroom fixtures, help the Chinese in ensuring a quality built housing environment.
You say you are 30 stories up. The building you are watching being contructed appears to be a steel framed building. A brick building cannot be built that high. The bricks are merely infill walls, not supporting the building at all.

While early infill buildings were built with the masonry acting as shear walls, modern buildings are built with such infill structurally independent of the frame. The gap you describe sounds like it needs to be there rather than it being defective construction.
So, I would not worry too much. :-)
http://www.conservationtech.com/RL's%20resume&%20pub's/RL-publications/Eq-pubs/1991-Woodrow/1991-Woodrow.htm
I just wanted to clarify to Owl, when I say they are building beside me, they are literally building beside me. Not beside my building, but they are constructing another apartment to my building, beside me. It's tough to explain, but imagine the building was built in levels and I was at the top of one of the levels. They are building up to my level from below, so I have an intimate view of what they are doing. And trust me when I say that the Chinese could use a lesson or two about construction and safety techniques from British Columbians. Not only has my apartment been under renovation but so has my office. An Australian colleague of mine was practically knocked out of his socks when he walked into a live wire hanging down from the ceiling. It's pretty scary.