Councillor Tries to Revise Budget Increase
By 250 News
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 08:28 PM
Prince George, B.C.- Councillor Dave Wilbur tried but failed to have Prince George City staff come up with a report by February 23rd on the options available to come up with a budget that would reduce the tax increase to under 1%. That would mean removing about $1.8 million dollars out of the budget as presented.
The current budget presented to Council is based on a 3.4% increase to cover the basic consumer price index increase.
Wilbur says the 3.4% that came forward was not something Council considered, “So I don’t feel any ownership to that 3.4%. I am aware of the current economic problems, and I am concerned things will get worse, but I think we should try our level best to hold the line. “
A one percent increase wasn’t Wilbur’s first choice “I have looked at the budgets that have been presented, and realize that zero percent would be nearly impossible, and that is why I came up with less than 1%”
Councillor Murry Krause would not support the motion saying the time period is too short, and to expect the staff to revise their budgets in a couple of weeks isn’t fair. He says he was on Council in the past when a zero increase budget was presented and it was not helpful, in fact he believes it made things worse.
Councillor Don Bassermann says this is an unfortunate motion in front of us. “When the zero percent budget was in front of us, the talks we have had these past few hours about road repairs and rehab are the result of that zero percent, and we cannot go back there. I cannot support this tonight. I don’t think its achievable and it’s a poor use of staff time.”
Councillor Cameron Stolz says the public needs to know that RCMP and Fire services alone increase the budget by 2.55% and the debt servicing increase is 1.44% “ I think staff have done a great job in presenting a budget that increases 3.4% , it shows their commitment to holding back spending. My personal approach has been how do we increase revenue?” He went on to say expecting staff to come up with a new budget within 12 days is not achievable.
Councillor Skakun says while he wants to be fiscally responsible, he cannot support it. “This tax increase is going to be less than the carbon tax being experienced by people today. So where do we take the money from, the bussing, the roads, the air quality initiatives? Which department is going to lose? I can appreciate where Councillor Wilbur is coming from, it’s not fair to administration, we’re half way through the budget process.”
Councillor Debora Munoz, says he would like to break with a trend “Every year we see a budget that is set with the Consumer price index, when government spending goes up it rarely comes down. I am not in support of every year Council being asked to support an inflationary budget at or above consumer price index.”
Councillor Sheri Green says she will support the motion, "I don’t know if 1% is the right percent, but I know that 3.4% doesn’t sit well with me. We haven’t challenged Administration to bring us something different.”
Mayor Dan Rogers says while he doesn’t support the motion, clearly he is hearing that this Council wants to do things differently. “We should start talking in terms and tell administration what pool we want to close? What service we want to lose? So the question is, what level of service do you want to provide? “ The Mayor says this budget “In my mind is a status quo budget and its maintaining the service levels we had. So if it makes you feel better, these are people who are spending money in your community. If we make a shift there are consequences. I understand how this got to the floor, but I don’t think this is prudent.”
The final vote had Councillors Wilbur, Munoz and Greene voting in favour of the motion,
Councillors Krause, Bassermann, Stolz, Skakun, Frizzell and the Mayor were opposed.
Previous Story - Next Story
Return to Home