Clear Full Forecast

Eurocan Closing - A Blow To The Entire North

By Ben Meisner

Thursday, October 29, 2009 03:45 AM

It is the most severe blow that the City of Kitimat could have ever received.

535 people will get their walking papers at the end of January, and Eurocan Pulp will cease to exist in that city.

Eurocan is the second largest industrial contributor of taxes to the city, and with that payroll is a very important part of the well being of that community.

It is a blow that Kitimat will have a hard time surviving.

What has caused it?  Several things,  first, there is an ever increasing competition for pulp and paper from third world countries who can produce the product much cheaper than we can in Canada. That will continue to be an ongoing problem in the industry and it is a problem that the three mills in Prince George face.

Eurocan  was not getting sufficient chips to enable it to operate efficiently, bearing in mind that the Port of Prince Rupert has been the area from which a lot of raw, round logs, are being exported . There are ships full of product heading out of the country to be milled overseas and there is little that either Eurocan, the Province or for that matter the federal government could do about it. The logs are, for the most part, being exported by First Nations in the area. They are coming from private land handed over by the Province in lands claims. The Province has no say in where these logs go.

In the past, mills operating in the Terrace area were supplying the company with chips, the only chips being received by Eurocan in recent months have been full sized raw logs. You cannot compete trying to operate in this manner.

While Terrace has been gradually poaching people and business away from Kitimat,  the closing of the mill will deal a blow to both communities.

The claim that the recession is all but over are hollow words indeed when it comes to the reality of what is happening around us. The problem is however that municipalities such as Prince George seem to be having a hard time getting  their minds around what really is happening in the community

I’m Meisner and that’s one man’s opinion


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

You fail to mention that the mills who did supply product to Eurocan, Smithers, Houston and Fraser Lake, will now direct their chip supplies to mills in Prince George and Quesnel.

That will have 2 strong effects on our economy, 1st it makes it more viable for local mills to shut down because there is now a bigger supply area to draw from, and 2nd it means less local loggers will be working this winter.

This area has more bettle kill wood than it can handle, but we will now be leaving more of it stand.

A great example of this is Dunkley Lumber, one of the few indipendant mills left. They brought in over 5000 loads of bettle kill timber this summer and fall to supply Canfor in PG. Last month they got word that they would no longer be shipping chips to Prince George this winter. They have a huge supply of logs on the ground with no other use. 2nd byproduct? As soon as they got word the announced a 2 week closure to all bug wood, opened for 2 weeks, then closed the mill to all wood for atleast one month. On top of that they have told all contractors no bug kill for the rest of the winter, what you have now you have to sit on and hope for the best.

This closure will effect the entire north.
Weekend shift at the PG mill chip plant has stopped as well. Loggers might have to get chip trailers and long haul from out west to stay working.

I don't think its sustainable to run a saw mill with out a regular chip contract, and a lot of mills aren't designed properly for stock pile... and the viability of hauling much past Fraser Lake to PG from a saw mills perspective might not be that great. This could mean the lose of thousands of forest industry jobs, with the only thing left west of Fraser Lake likely to be raw log exports in 5-years time. Without a forest industry the north would be depopulated.

I was reading this article the other day that says the newsprint market volume is in free fall. Down 10.6% in September alone.
http://www.reuters.com/article/email/idUSN2633378520091026

You can bet that factored into Eurocans decision... ditto for the financeers manipulation of our dollar.
The log export by the bands are not from the land claim settlement as you stated.

These are from TFL 1, which had been a part of Skeena Cellulose. When the mill was sold to a consortium of local businessmen, TFL #1 was sold to the Port Simpson Band, along with the log yard. The Terrace Lumber Company, which tried to run the mill, eventually closed down because of lack of timber.

This was something which the province DID have control over, as they are the ones who allowed the timber and the mill to be sold separately.
The biggest problem for Eurocan was the net price it was receiving for it's products, particularly, linerboard. The market for linerboard has tanked and their other product, unbleached paper (Sack Kraft)is not great either. Combined with the strengthening of the Canadian dollar, this put the final nails in the coffin for that mill. Note I said FINAL. Their coffin has been under construction for a long time. It may have seemed sudden to most - and they kept the secret very well - but it is not at all surprising to many.
Companies have been exporting logs from Prince Rupert to Japan/China since the 1960's. Also from the Queen Charlottes, and other West Coast Cities, so this isnt anything new.

The reasons for Euorcans demise is pretty well summed up by Good Citizen.

BC and Canada can no longer compete on the world market with all our high costs.

a. Transportation
b. Fibre
c. Labour
d. Management
e. Government red tape.
f. Worksafe BC

g. etc; etc; etc;

When you can export logs to foreign countries and then buy their finished product and have it shipped back, you know you have a problem.

Can the problem be solved. This will depend on the Three Amigo's.

(1) Big Government
(2) Big Business
(3) Big Unions

These three entities have been feeding off Joe Citizen for a long time, and havent put anything back in the pot. I suspect they dont have the wherewithal to tie their shoes, and therefore we are really in trouble.


So how do the Scandinavians compete, I know they have their issues too, but they pay better wages, better benefits, more taxes etc.
We have good fibre, supply is in correction, and we (PG area) have chips close by. Pulp prices are up again. Oh and thanks to the taxpayers we also have 120 sum billion to invest in local mills. I'm optimistic PG will be fine.
My condolences to the good people of the Terrace/ Kitimat area. Get to work Mr. Cullen
Time to put the Eurocan mill on Craigslist in Quangdong province in China? Wait a year or until they express interest.
How do we know the Scandinavians are competing? From what I have heard they are suffering every bit as much as us.

On an ironic note, one of the worst things to happen to the pulp industry is the very thing were discussing this on, the internet.

Newspapers are a thing of the past.
We don't make newsprint here.
Try wipin' yer arse with your laptop!
The Scans are hurting just as much, if not more than us. Their Fibre costs are much higher and they have ceased getting Russian wood due to an exhorbitant tariff. The demand for Paper products, environmental pressure and raw material costs and the world wide economic downturn have hurt the industry world wide. Yet the mills in Prince George continue to do reasonably well. Maybe it's time we stopped bashing them and thank them for being responsible operators and forward thinking business people.
GoodCitizen
Agreed 100%
I noticed you didn't mention how labour is a factor, it really isn't. If people think Canadians are payed too much, maybe we should all take a 20% wage cut. Oh wait a minute, thats happening now, goodbye consumer economy.