Clear Full Forecast

Survey Says You Support Cell Phone Ban for Drivers

By 250 News

Friday, November 13, 2009 03:56 AM

Prince George, B.C.- A  new IPSOS AREID  survey indicates British Columbians  support the new  regulations for   cell phone use while  driving.

A strong majority of residents support the ban (92%), with three-quarters of the population “strongly supporting” it (75%).

The poll also asked whether residents support various other aspects of the ban. There is nearly universal support for the ban on sending/receiving text messages (96% total support, 93% strongly support) and sending/receiving emails while driving (98% total support, 94% strongly support). There is also strong support for the ban on using hands-free devices for new drivers under the Graduated License Program (89% total support, 73% strongly support) and moderate support for exceptions to the legislation for police, fire and ambulance drivers while working during emergencies.

What’s more, one-third (34%) believe  the provincial government should have gone one step further to prohibit the use of hands-free devices while driving as well. Older residents are much more likely to agree with this compared to their younger counterparts. Nearly half of those over the age of 55 (45%) think that the provincial government should ban hands-free devices as well, compared to just over half (28%) of those aged 35 to 54 and 29% of those 18 to 34.

One month after the ban is put in place, on February 1, 2010, drivers caught using a cell phone will be fined $167. Over one-third (36%) feel that this fine is too low. A further 44% feel that it is about right, while 17% think it is too high. Those aged 18-34 are more likely to think the fine is too high (25% of 18-34 compared to 10% of 55+). Similarly, males (22%) are also more likely to think the fine is too high relative to females (11%)

The poll also finds that a minority of residents plan to break the law. When asked what activities BC residents expect to participate in while driving after the new legislation comes into place, just under one-in-ten (7%) admit that they will talk on a non-hands-free phone while driving, 5% will use hand-held music or portable gaming devices, 2% will read/send text messages and 1% will read/send emails. Males and younger age groups are more likely to admit to making an infringement here. Those aged 18 to 34 (13% compared to 2% of those 55+) and males (12% versus 3% of females) confess that they will talk on their cell phones while driver after the legislation passes.


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

With the technology we have today, there must be devices that can be installed in vehicles, to jamb the signal! A cell phone should not be used in a vehicle that is in motion, period! Hands free doesn't even cut it, these fools are texting, putting on their make up (so they look pretty in the morgue I would guess) eating breakfast, changing tunes on the stereo, brushing their teeth, shaving, and the list goes on and on. There should be no use of cell phones, or any other electronic advice within 5 meters of a vehicle!

We live in such a stunned world these days. Does nobody have any common sense anymore?
Onstar...at least you can't text with it while driving and you don't have to dial!
You just talk to it!
What a concept!
Me thinks it is about to become a very popular option in a GM product even though it has been around for years.
Ford has a system now as well I understand, but don't know what it is called.
Yes and from what the commercial shows it dials the company when in an accident. For those trapped for days at a time down embankments this would have been a plus.

I find the fine for talking on cells is a good start. If too many people break it then up it.
Watch out for all the stopped vehicles all over the streets and highways.
I send and receive 30 to 40 cell phone calls a day, sometimes more, it's part of my job. People will have to be patient since I can no longer answer the phone. I for one am 100% for this new law as I see insane uses by all sorts of people everyday. One question comes to mind though, can you pull over and call the person back? If you are in your car but parked .. is it still illegal?
Love to be a bluetooth reseller in 2010.

Also, who do these surveyers call... they never asked me... :)
This is a good law, but I foresee a lot of abuse. I don't imagine the cops will pull over every driver they see holding a hand to their head. Personally, I think the hands free devices are not much safer, as I believe the real issue is with concentration, not whether you have one, or two, hands on the steering wheel.
metalman.
my phone rings in the middle of a conversation with my collegues, they ask, if I am going to answer it. I say nope.

I have a cell phone to serve me, not to serve the cell phone.

I agree metalman. I'm sure we've all yelled at someone to get off the phone when we're stuck behind them at a green light. Or stuck behind them while they zig zag the yellow line. Concentration.
Concentration!!!!!!

Don't think, just drive.

Shut all thinking off. Just drive.

Don't talk to your passenger. Just drive.

Don't listen to others in the car talk. Just drive.

Don't listen to the radio. Just drive.

Don't smoke. Just drive.

Don't listen to or view your GPS. Just drive.

Don't adjust the temperature of your car. Just drive.

Don't lower the window. Just drive.

Don't use a standard. Just drive an automatic.

I think that if hands free communication systems are banned, then a lot of other activities in the vehicle need to be looked at first.
Acrider54 has it right. Are we going to see cars veering over to the side of the road so that they can answer the phone?? Probably.

If all those people who were surveyed are in favour of this legislation, then why do we have a problem.

92% supported the ban. Can one assume that the supporters are not now using the phones. Or will they just discontinue using them once it becomes illegal. If its the latter than they are nothing more than a bunch of hyprocrites. If it is dangerous, and endangers other peoples lives, everone should stop now, not wait for February.

Voice mail use will rise significantly. If people want to avoid the urge to answer the phone then I suggest that they turn in off when they are in their vehicles.



Well maybe the only real solution would be to start building vehicles with a device that deactivates cell phones or interrupts service while the engine is running.

Maybe in my next life I'll be an inventor.
;)
I agree with Gus. And if you are gonna ban hands-free, you should also ban passengers. No talking in the car whatsoever.
hmmm, it seems we dont have enough RCMP officers to keep the speeding to a minimum, I bet their going to spend lots of time with cell phones.
More laws = more law breakers. The government needs to back off on all this nonsense.
Darn the idea is already out there:
http://www.geeksugar.com/3072415

Oh well.. :)
Still some flaws with the idea as stated in this article:http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,480585,00.html

But when you read these quotes who cares if a phone is working or not in the vehicle for passengers to use.

"One of the worst accidents occurred last year in New York, when five teens were killed when their 17-year-old driver, carrying on a text conversation, collided with a tractor-trailer rig.

B. Michael Adler, chief executive of WQN, said his 18-year-old son came to mind as he was developing the company's software to disable a cell phone while driving.

"He's texting messages with two hands and driving with his legs," Adler said. "You flip him the keys to the family car, you might as well be flipping him a six-pack of beer."
I’m going north on Ospika in the outside lane the other day when I catch up to this rig it’s a sleigh that some guy has put wheels under as there is no snow yet. He is wearing a red coat with this peaked hat that has a tassel on the end. And you wont believe this but its being pulled by eight tiny reign deers. He’s on the Cell phone making a left turn at Ospika and 15th. He’s on the center line using both turn slots. People are flashing their lights and blowing their horns.

He cut off the guy behind him making a right turn into Timmy’s. The guy is blowing his horn and shaking his fist but the old guy just keeps on trucking. He’s at the order board still on his phone. The person at the desk doesn’t know if they are being talked to or what’s happening. When he gets to the takeout window the old girl almost hawks up her faults teeth. She hands him his donut and coffee that was finally ordered. He gives her twenty bucks and says keep the change. He mutters something about these Prince George drivers are the mos t stupid in the world all they ever do is whine about my driving habits.

He tweaks his nose and he’s off towards the horse in the sky. He is last seen in the Casino Hotel parking lot with a fist full of money heading for the entrance.

Cheers
That's a good point, EBS&L, it occurred to me too; how different is it talking to a passenger vs. hands free on a cell phone?
After some consideration, I believe there is a difference. When you are engrossed in a telephone conversation, your concentration tends, I think, to be with the person you are speaking to, or the subject you are discussing, When the person is sitting beside you, less concentration is needed to carry your side of the conversation, maybe because of body language, or being in close proximity, I don't know, that's how it works for me anyway.
metalman.
Quite possibly true MM, but the the real problem is the govt trying to legislate every minute detail of peoples lives instead of educating or even encouraging people to use common sense. Because there are some breathtakingly stupid people in the world (like the 18 year old in Heidi's post) we are all treated like idiots.
I agree with gus and EBS&L. But really making an exception for police, fire and ambulance?!
A few months back, a female cop ran a red light because she had her phone to her ear. I had a green and was forced to stop so I didn't plow into her door. No lights no siren. She was just toodling along oblivious to traffic.

I don't think they should have exceptions either.
If 92% are in favour of the ban then we dont need this law - obviously only 8% of the population talks on thier phone while driving... right?
hmmmmm
The advantage of talking to a passenger rather than someone on the phone is that the passenger is a second pair of eyes. Using a front seat passenger as a co-driver or navigator is a tactic for driving more safely on forestry roads, for instance.
Plus when on the phone while driving you tend to not tune out to the person...you tune out to the traffic/pedestrians. When you are having people talk in your vehicle like say your husband you tend to tune out and pay attention to traffic. You know it's true!

;)
Retired, don't you ever get tired of putting that same post on time after time? Or can't you think of anything else to say?
Yes, there are many things that can distract you when you drive, cell phones are probably the worst offender.

When I see somebody doing something stupid or not paying attention on the road, 90% of the time, they're blabbering on a cell phone. Yes, adjusting the temperature or other such activities are distractions too, but not near as much as cell phone use. Let's not confuse the issue.

For the people who are deluded enough to believe that they're great drivers talking on a cell phone, too bad.