Clear Full Forecast

Get Out Migration Walk Closing In On Goal

By 250 News

Thursday, May 06, 2010 10:07 AM

Prince George, B.C. – Fish Biologist Alexandra Morton is closing in on her goal, reaching Victoria having walked the length of Vancouver Island to spread the word that salmon are sacred.
 
Morton has been the most vocal   force for bringing an end to open net salmon farming. Her walk, which started on April 23rd in Sointula at the north end of Vancouver Island, is called Get Out Migration. “This is a call to action to make government aware that we want wild salmon to take higher priority than farm salmon.  Farms belong on land.”
 
Morton says her walk has been an emotional one. Speaking on the Meisner program on CFISFM this morning, Morton says she is being greeted by hundreds of people “ We are walking to tell people that if they simply stand up and make themselves visible to government, there is no reason we have to lose our wild salmon. But as we walk into towns with our flags flying, brilliant salmon signs, singing “we are walking to Victoria to save our fish,” an entirely unexpected thing is happening. People are coming up to me and holding me - crying. They are speaking about schools without children, independent livelihoods lost, communities dying. This is about much more than fish.”
 
Morton says she doesn't know  if  the efforts will ever get through to  provincial and federal government but she says, "We are giving it our best try."  Morton says  initially,  she would have been have been  satisfied if the fish farms were  located  somewhere other than on a salmon migration route, "But now, my feeling is,  just, get out."   She says there are Canadian copmpanies which want to  farm  salmon  at operations established on land, but she says the Provincial government  won't  discuss  those plans.  She says  such operations would pick up the  jobs lost from  aquaculture.   She says once the aqua culture farms are gone,   the focus can be  put back on reviving the wild salmon stocks " We as biologists know what these fish need.  If we work with these fish rather than against them, I think we would be surprised.  Alaska is having record runs,  Western Pacific is having huge runs,  you can't  have all the  Fraser River Salmon running through these farms where we know there is disease as well as sea lice."
 
Morton’s walk will culminate with a 4 p.m rally at the B.C. Legislature on Saturday.

Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

"Well, consider this: Mr. Olesiuk also calculated how many salmon fry the seals were eating in the spring: 3.1 million."

“They take 60 to 70 chum fry, per minute, per seal,” he says. “They eat the young fish like popcorn.”

"Mr. Olesiuk’s latest coast-wide census, to be released this week, shows B.C.’s seal and sea lion populations are at historic high levels."

"There are an estimated 105,000 harbour seals on the coast – up from about 10,000 in the early 1970s – and 28,000 Steller’s sea lions, the highest number since the early 1900s."

"In Scotland, a study found that taking a single seal out of the Moriston River increased the sports salmon catch by 17 per cent. On other rivers, removing seals had varying results, with salmon catches increasing from less than 1 per cent to more than 33 per cent."

"He favours a seal cull, but added: “It’s pointless to kill seals if you don’t address the other problems, too. I think salmon farms and hydro projects do more damage.” Notice he thinks, is that science? Morton's studies do not stand up to peer review. At one time she said all west coast salmon are affected by salmon farms but seeing that is not panning out she is narrowing it down to the Fraser. She is running out of wiggle room that is why she is getting more vocal.

"We as biologists know what these fish need."

There's your problem right there. Arrogance. If she had a clue, she'd know Hell's Gate is the 300 pound gorilla in the room.
"In Scotland, a study found that taking a single seal out of the Moriston River increased the sports salmon catch by 17 per cent. On other rivers, removing seals had varying results, with salmon catches increasing from less than 1 per cent to more than 33 per cent."

So human entertainment take precedence over wildlife?
It is more important to "manage" a sport fishery than have a robust wildlife population?
Seals are pests?

Loki don't you think that would also apply to the food fishery.
By Robert Wager, The Daily News May 8, 2010

Everyone wants to protect wild salmon.

But there is the rub. What is actually threatening the wild stocks?

Alexandra Morton would have us believe sea lice from fish farms are a major threat.

I would like to say why a great many career marine scientists do not agree with Morton.

Morton's published statistical model predicted the pink salmon in the Broughton would be extinct by 2010.

This year saw very good returns of pink to that region.

Morton claims 1 to 3 sea lice can be fatal to young salmon yet the Pacific salmon forum report (four years of research including Morton's) states: "Duration of survival of juvenile salmon decreased with increased lice loads but this effect was only statistically supported when lice loads were an order of magnitude (10 times) greater than levels reported in nature."

Morton claims sea lice from fish farms are killing sockeye salmon from the Fraser River yet the sockeye are far too large, according to peer reviewed research, for any impacts on mortality from sea lice when the sockeye pass the Broughton.

Research shows sea lice levels in the Broughton are 20 to 100 times lower those found during the historic high of 2004.

Research (far from fish farms) show sea lice are generated on herring to levels far greater than those presently found in the Broughton.

Many have a difficult time understanding the "Protect the wild salmon, eat only wild salmon" philosophy. It makes far more sense to reduce the pressures on wild stocks by supplying an alternative source of healthy salmon for the hungry consumer.

Robert Wager

Vancouver Island University