Clear Full Forecast

HST Survey Says Media Partly to Blame for Residents Poor Understanding of New Tax

By 250 News

Sunday, June 27, 2010 04:33 AM

Prince George, B.C.-  With less than a week to go before the harmonized sales tax (HST) becomes effective in B.C.,  and new Ipsos Reid Pre-HST Study reveals  the vast majority of adult British Columbians continue to strongly oppose the new tax (78% oppose, with 65% strongly oppose and 13% somewhat oppose), and say  they will dramatically alter their purchasing behavior as a result of the HST.

According to the study, residents feel the HST will have a negative impact on them personally (80% agree), for British Columbians overall (85%), but less of a negative impact on small (62%) and large (40%) retailers in the province. Residents also believe the HST will have a negative impact on the overall BC economy (55% agree), and put some small business owners out of business (59% agree).

The study found   B.C.residents  don't have a very good  understanding of the HST and they blame government and the media for poorly communicating the effect of the tax to the consumer.

Of a list of 10 exempt items, very few residents (6-35%) were able to correctly identify them.  Only one-third correctly identified the exemption for basic groceries (35%), about the same number are aware that residential rent (32%), children’s items such as clothing, footwear and diapers (31%) and prescription drugs (25%) will be exempt from HST. At the bottom end, only 17% are aware of child care service exemptions, 8% for legal aid as well as books, and only 6% for music lessons. Residents are divided on whether they have a good understanding of the benefits of the HST (62% agree, 35% disagree), but feel they have a good understanding of the drawbacks (75%). Only 6% agree they feel the government has done a good job communicating about the HST (6%), and 54% feel the media has not done a good job either.

A significant majority of British Columbians claim they will be spending less on the goods and services that will be subject to the HST but have previously been taxed at a lower rate. In fact, in 18 of 23 categories covered, the percentage of consumers who say they will spend less exceeds the number who will not change their spending level. Seven-in-ten British Columbians who dine out (70%) say they will reduce their spending on restaurant meals when the HST becomes effective. Six-in-ten consumers of snack foods will also be reducing their spending (63%). Coincidentally, six in ten residents who buy tickets to professional sporting events, live theatre and music concerts will also reduce their spending in these areas (61%). The only areas consumers will not cut back in are vitamins, over-the-counter medications, utility bills, and haircuts.

Other cost-saving measures are ready to be implemented by consumers as a backlash to the HST. The majority of British Columbians (85%) are likely to more often or more actively look for sales as a result of the HST (55% very likely, 30% somewhat likely). Most are also likely to buy less overall or reuse what they already have (83%, with 43% very likely and 40% somewhat likely), and use more coupons (73%), and buy more generic brands (68%).

Also starting July 1, 2010, Washington State will apply its non-resident sales tax exemption to British Columbians. Under this policy, BC residents will not have to pay sales tax in Washington State for goods used outside the state. Approximately half of British Columbians (54%) are likely to shop in Washington State as a result of this exemption (31% a lot more likely and 23% a little more likely).


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

While people may not have an encyclopedic knowledge of every exempt good or service, it is clear they understand very well the increased costs we are all going to pay.

Surveys of this type, which seek to clarify how well people understand the effects of the tax, miss the mark completely. The objections to the HST have little to do with what is and what is not to be taxed. It is about being lied to and resenting it. The anger is over the deliberate deception of Campbell, Hansen and the rest of them, categorically stating that the HST was not on the radar, then moving to implement it a few days after being elected. Cynical betrayal comes to mind.
I would love to hear the explanation on how this will create new jobs. Before the recession we had a labour shortage.
When you have a significant tax shift of $1.9 Billion from Business and Corporations, to consumers, it matters little what it applies on. The fact of the matter is, is that it is a tax shift.

Leave the PST where it is, and let Business and Corporations pay their share.

No more Corporate welfare. Most of whats produced in this Province is exported, so there will be no reduction in prices.

Biggest BS story in years.
Your article states that childrens clothing is exempt...apparently the hst is being applied by size? so if your kid is a football player you pay hst on his duds!

""children’s items such as clothing, footwear and diapers (31%) and prescription drugs (25%) will be exempt from HST.""

I've heard it both ways from the media, so yes the media is messing up the message.
Hey! It is not all bad! Luxury vehicles are getting a 3% tax break.
Happy Tax day BC!
I agree completely with the first three posts. Aside from that, the whole HST implementation process has been the most ham-handed, inept, governmental exercise I've ever seen in regards to any tax, ever.

Right from the way the HST was announced straight through to the things it will, or will not, apply to.

In our business we're still in limbo as to whether mill waste sold to the public as firewood will be taxable at 5%, as it is now (GST applies, PST does not), or 12% under HST. There is something called a "point-of-sale rebate", but not a word about how that's supposed to work. We're told that the remission period, monthly in our case, will be the same in one place, and change to every three months in another. Which is it?

And the List of things now taxable under HST that weren't taxable under PST is woefully incomplete. There's six things in our business alone, (if firewood is included), that aren't on that List.

I strongly suspect, from talking to other small business owners, that they're facing similar inadequacies in their businesses.

For two Parties that pride themselves in being so "business-savvy", both the Harper Conservatives and, especially, Campbell's Liberals, are exhibiting an ineptitude of the same nature they're so fond of attributing to the NDP. What we've had in the way of explanations have been no more than excuses from day one. It is a stupid tax, imposed by a stupid government, on what they were sure would be a public too stupid to object. Only the public, this time, has proved them both wrong. Keep up the pressure, folks, WE CAN BEAT THIS THING ~ and they're going to yield, or be gone.
I doubt it's the media that's messing up the message. It's that the message is messed up BEFORE it gets to the media. By the same kind of high-priced help that advised that white-haired bonehead we have as Premier to bring the HST in. High-priced help that, if we're REALLY in such desperate financial straits as is made out, should be the FIRST to be dismissed.
so far no reduction in hydro phone,cable, gas, liquor prices, food and if you live in any any type of strata you will be paying hst on your strata fees
yes there are some items none that will benefit myself in the near future but the adjustment in the carbon tax will soon take care of that or anything else they happened to miss,
Did this artical come from the govt. p.a.b. ? I feel incenced reading this... my costs are and will go up, I'm not stupid and Í dont need some hack news story put out telling me the media didnt do its job in informing me as to how great its going to be as I shell out more money for basics! as for the media please spare me the msm in this province havent been doing their jobs for a very long time, if you think this is about saving your services... not one penny of the hst will go to any public service we now have.. its a tax shift people! from big business to consumers plain and simple
Electoral fraud keeps coming to my mind
Due to the HST petition, the government has not been allowed to try to explain the HST to the public. They tried and Elections BC said they were interfering with the petition process.
When the First Nations folks of BC will be exempt from this tax, that will be the icing on the cake.
I'll make my major purchases to Alberta...I can see the governement collection the HST at the U.S. border...would love to see them try that at the Alberta border...
I don't want to have to stop patronizing local but with the HST, I'll go where I must, as long as it aint US products...
So BCRacer, what will you purchase in Alberta that you wouldn't have paid both PST and GST on before?
Of all the letters I sent to liberal MLA's only Kevin Krueger, MLA Kamloops - South Thompson responded.

My letter had to deal with the electoral fraud they committed on the people of BC in how they implemented this, the loss of taxation sovereignty for future generations in BC, and asked that they respect the petition process and the will of the people. I mentioned their was nothing stopping them from adjusting the PST to meet some of the criteria they claim the HST will create.

The response I got from Kevin Krueger argued the HST is needed or we won't be competitive anymore with Ontario (they would 'devastate us' he claims), and they will take all our investments away from us if we don't follow their lead once they decided to go with HST, and that it eliminates 400 jobs from the BC payroll... that the BC Small Business Round Table called for it whom they were responding to and that they cut regulations on business by 43% since coming to power. Oh and the $1.6 billion they will get in bribe money from the Harper government that is essential for 'health care and education' to be maintained.

All of it missed the point completely and was basically talking over the concerns I had, which were in no way addressed.

The icing on the cake though was the attacks on Bill Vander Zalm with links to articles on Vander Zalm's past as a political chameleon and bringing up all the past dirt that was used to run Vander Zalm out of provincial politics from fantasy gardens to the Expo sale and essentially painting anyone that opposes the HST with association to Vander Zalm's past problems. You know they have no real argument when they resort to attacking Vander Zalm's past to justify their current policy.

At the end of the day I still feel bring on the Vander Zlam proscription list, because it is well needed now more than at any other time in our provinces history. What ever Vander Zalms past problems were he is more than making up for it now by being the voice of the majority of people in this province when the official opposition isn't able to.

Time will tell....
Ruez
There is no PST on anything in Alberta.
I remember once upon a time when Willie Wooden Shoes was gonna be elected and he said he would do something about marketing boards. Like Joe Clark and his "tax deductible mortgage dream". they both lied.
Its a shame but I know countless people who buy in Grande Prairie or Edmonton for all home appliances--some have even purchased a wood stove or furnace. Why not? This Govt is too greedy, just like our local council, and spends it foolishly. Olympics,winter games are two things that have, and will, eat up obscene amounts of money and stick in my craw for a long time. I haven't forgotten the NDP and their spending habits either. Vote BC refederation for govt by us and for us.
Kolberg, the government had ample time to fully explain the HST right down to the last detail well BEFORE the Petition process officially got underway.

What's come from them so far is nothing more than a litany of confusing contradictions.

First it's going to be remitted every three months. Now, if you remit GST and PST monthly, then that's the way you'll remit HST. Which is it? The two governments can't seem to get their act together.

Why should we in business, who have more than enough other things to do, have to try to ferret out this information for ourselves?

A recent issue of the Building Supply Industry Dealers Association's trade magazine had a run down on some of the new rules as they thought they applied transitionally, but now it seems like they don't.


It's just completely inane the way the governments have proceeded on this whole hair brained fiasco. I hope we Recall them all, and through that send a strong message to their successors, whoever they may be, that the same thing will be in store for them if they don't buck-up and start listening to the people they're supposed to be representing.
I think both Bill Vander Zalm and Joe Clark found out once they'd attained office that even Premiers and Prime Ministers can't always do what they'd like to do.
"There is no PST on anything in Alberta."

I understand that. I used to live there.
We have had a form of HST since the end of WWII. Since that time, the federal and provincial governments have gradually been lowering corporate tax rates while adding new taxes and user fees onto the public.

The claims of job creation and increasing Canada's ability to attract investment ring hollow.
This HST has nothing to do with creating jobs. It's just another hand-out to the special interests who contribute to right wing governments.

Gordo Campbell knows his time is running out and the HST is his parting gift to the people who have funded his political carreer.
I'm predicting he ends up working as a mouthpiece for some resource or energy company.

Robert Waite,

I predict Campbell will move to the Uniteed States.

BC is the "best place on earth" when he's advertising to us BC residents on TV, but when he goes on holiday, he goes to Hawaii.

We're the ones who are supposed to blindly take "staycations" to support BC, not him.

God knows what kind of investments he's made in the USA.
The HST's really a gift to the Banks, Robert. It'll improve the rate of reported profit amongst their largest BC corporate customers, because the PST on capital purchases funded through borrowings will no longer be a part of those business' capital costs. This will lower their capital cost allowance that's expensed as depreciation, and improve their profits.

Since the principal of every corporate Bank loan is amortised from profit, higher profits enable the Banks to safely underwrite larger loans.

Only they WON'T be used for job creation ~ we're long past the 'pioneering' stage in most of our economic activities now, when such investment actually did lead to new, and often long-term, job creation.

Nowadays, such funds will more likely be spent on job elimination through labour displacing enhancements to productivity. Since employment costs are one of the very few areas any corporation has in which its costs can still be controlled by itself.

My prediction is that Gordo's eventual post-politics reward will be a well-paid seat on the Board of Directors of one, or more, of our major Banks.
I asked myself where did that HST-for-Ontario/B.C. idea germinate? Answer: In Harper's spin office! What's in it for him and his government and the interests who support his government?

Surely he doesn't care whether it benefits a province or not as long as it gives Ottawa what it he wants: More control!

Even if Campbell had explained it before the election I would still be against it because I do not support Harper and his usually cynical manipulations.



Revenue stations along the BC and the Alberta border to collect the tax from major purchases made in cheaper Alberta. They do it on our southern border. Why not on our eastern border? If they do, hey, it is job creation, ain't it?