Clear Full Forecast

Dunster Dealings: Offers and Counter-Offers

By Michelle Cyr-Whiting

Thursday, July 22, 2010 09:04 PM

Prince George, B.C. -  The Dunster Fine Arts School Society has until noon tomorrow to submit a response to School District 57, as the wrangling continues over the fate of the elementary school.

The school was one of six slated to close at the end of the school year, as District 57's Board of Trustees was forced to deal with a $5.2-million dollar budget shortfall.

Parents in the small community have been trying everything they can think of to breathe new life into the school -- they occupied the building for a short time at the end of June, until forced out by a court order.  Earlier this month, they formed the society and put in a bid to buy the school and property it sits on, with the hopes of then having School District 57 provide the educational services.

Now, DFASS spokesperson, Chris Taylor, says members are reeling after receiving a 10-page counter-offer from the district that's asking fair-market value for the land. 

Taylor says District 57's $39.5-thousand dollar counter-offer is a far cry from the $10-dollar nominal offer they were encouraged to make by school district administration at a meeting back on June 14th.

Taylor says the society is in the process of trying to come up with a counter-offer of its own before tomorrow's noon deadline.  She says she spent all of today on the phone and had hoped to speak with Education Minister, Margaret MacDiarmid directly, but, with the minister away, Taylor is waiting to hear back from someone in her office.  The Dunster parent is also waiting to hear back from local MLA Shirley Bond.

Taylor says, "We just feel, really, that the board is being extremely unreasonable and we're all still really in shock over the counter-offer that they've put forth."

School District 57 Board Chair, Lyn Hall, is uncomfortable discussing details of the offers.  He says the Board decided it needed to counter the DFASS's original offer and include some guidelines it felt needed to be put in place.

"I certainly don't recall us saying that a $10-dollar amount would be what we're looking for," says Hall.  "And I don't want to get into a debate in the media with Dunster and I'm not going to use the media to negotiate."

"I don't want to speak specifically about whay may happen or what has happened -- the negotiating, I think, needs to take place between us and the Dunster Society."

Both Hall and Chris Taylor feel a face-to-face meeting between members of the DFASS, school district staff and board members would be helpful, but both say finding a date and time that works is a difficult task in the summer.

For his part, Hall says, "I think what's do-able is the sale of the facility.  I think we can come to an agreement there."  The educational component may be more challenging.  He says if the community chooses to use the Centre for Learning Alternative's distance education as a program that would work for the fall, but, Hall says, SD57 would not be able to offer up an educational component until the 2011-2012 school year.


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

Why is step one to purchase the building? All this energy into purchasing the building is a waste. Just rent it and focus on the more important issues of starting a private school.

When you start any new venture you focus on the core operations. Buying a building is something you do after you have a sucessful operation.
The previous article on this stated that Superintendent Pepper said the School District will receive funding … dollars are linked to the students ….. whatever choices are made, the dollars will follow the students and will stream through those options

Now it says that Hall says, "I think what's do-able is the sale of the facility. I think we can come to an agreement there." The educational component may be more challenging.

Sounds like two different opinions to me.

Time for people to get together in one room, work it out and leave the room when they have an agreement.

As far as the facility goes, rent to own over 5 years for $700/month. Or $375/mo for 10 years.

But as Kolberg says, make sure that there are delivery dollars in place for this fall and into the future.
Just recall Shirley Bond....talk about an insult to the people of Dunster!!
Fair is fair...it should be sold for fair market value. Everyone else purchasing closed schools has to do the same. This should not be any different. It's tax dollars.
It's good to see that the ten dollar offer was rejected. I feel sorry for the kids that are about to endure a longer bus ride but that's the downside to living in the boonies. There are a lot of schools that were recently closed; are we going to sell them all for ten bucks? If you give a break to one special interest group you're going to be hounded by the next group for a similar deal.


I can't wait for the next election so that we can turf Lyn Hall and the rest of the trustees. We need people in place who put the kids first.
People with children that normally ought to go to school are a special interest group?

We are all members of special interest groups.

So those who want to breathe clean air are members of a special interest group?

Those who want roads fixed?

Those who want to pay less taxes?

Those who want recycling?

And on and on .....

Why do people who might have a passionate interest in something that affects their lives get labled with that term "special interest" which then is supposed to make them less important?

Kinda puts you in a special interest group of irresponsible labelling that ought to be ignored.
They are a group of parents who are rallying to keep their school open. That's their special interest; they are not concerned with other schools, just their own. Hence the term, "special interest group".

Being a special interest group doesn't imply that they are any less important than any one else. I'm not sure where you pulled that idea from.
they have money to send teachers to Vegas [sin city] and the mayor of pg & two cohorts to China, MLAs collect thousands for lunch money...but they have to get full market value for the old school??

It's pretty easy to see what is important to this government and it sure isn't our rural communities.
Faxman: "If you give a break to one special interest group you're going to be hounded by the next group for a similar deal"

Those were your words.

The follow up to that is that anyone or any organization that can be attached to a special interest should not be given "a break".

That, in my mind makes them "less important" since they cannot be handled differently than others.

The elderly are special interest groups, thus cannot be given special consideration just because they are elderly. The list of those cases of special interests is endless. We cannot all be put into the same category. We all have some sort of special needs. Get rid of that notion and the entire system we have built up would crumble.
Faxman: "They are a group of parents who are rallying to keep their school open. That's their special interest; THEY ARE NOT CONCERNED WITH OTHER SCHOOLS, JUST THEIR OWN."

What leads you to think that they are not concerned with other schools? People can be concerned about more than just one thing. It is amazing the capacity that people have.

Taht being said, most people act best in a hierarchy of local to global, not global to local. In doing so, it is also amazing that normally those things that are of concern locally are also of concern globally. Thus if a "local" problem has been addressed to everyone's satisfaction, the method or result are often universally applicable. The notion of the English system of "common law" is the best example of that.

You cite it by writing: "If you give a break to one special interest group you're going to be hounded by the next group for a similar deal."

BINGO!!!!!! The advent of common practice and common law. What is equitable for one group is equitable for another.

Our society is formed on the notion of precedence. It has been accepted since the 13th century to be the just way of doing things.

And you hope to change it?! :-)