Clear Full Forecast

Simpson to Sit as Independent

By 250 News

Thursday, October 07, 2010 08:35 AM

Prince George,  B.C. -Cariboo North MLA Bob Simpson will be sitting as an independent in the provincial legislature for now, after being kicked out of caucus by NDP leader Carole James.
James made the move last night after speaking with Simpson about some comments he made on the Welcome to Williams Lake website about her speech to the Union of BC Municipalities.
In the comments, Simpson critiqued  the speeches of all three political party leaders, in the case of James he wrote:
 "The Leader of the Opposition likewise had little concrete to offer the delegates other than a commitment to be more consultative than the current government and a promise to explore the possibility of revenue sharing with local governments. This is a timely concept which has the potential to address the resource needs of local governments, but the lack of specifics was a disappointment to delegates."
Simpson has been the MLA for Cariboo North since 2005.
When asked what happened, Simpson said "It's called the ultra sensitivity of party politics in British Columbia."  He says it speaks of  "no discenting voice even if it is mild discent".
Simpson says the  move is the result of a "slow burn"  as a result in part of his  regular weekly column on the Williams Lake  website. "I have written in the past, being just as critical of the opposition  as  I have been of the other parties,  the UBCM is a chance for each of the  political party leaders to  set out their agendas for the coming year, and I said that I didn't think that any of the leaders took advantage of that."  He says in two sentences he panned  Premier Campbell's speech and  Stockwell Day's address and  the leader of the green party and says he was kicked out of caucus for saying Carole James' speech  lacked details.
Simpson says  his riding association has put forth a motion calling for a full leadership  convention in 2011.  "Fully  two thirds  of British Columbians, after 7 years  as Carole as leader, still don't  have an opinion of her or  don't believe she can be Premier.  I've been addressing that,  in particular since spring  I've been saying look, we're riding the HST gravy train  but its not giving us purpose.  We're not moving in the polls , Carole's numbers are not moving, our party's  in disarray, our membershjip is  walking and we need to do something more dramatic  and expansive.  And for the NDP we need to try and convince British Columbians  that we have the right  to govern,  we know what we want to govern to, and  we actually get a mandate and that's always been important to me.   I think that is the backdrop, the excuse is the two sentences in my column.  The reality is I had a meeting scheduled, for face to face  with me and Carole James next week to bring this to a head  and I think what's happening is they're avoiding that confrontation."
Simpson says British Columbians  don't elect governments, they just boot the others out,  and he would like to see  a return to  a government being elected because of its plans and visions "Elections should not be about  nasty ads and sound bites to take the other person down, they should  be a fight about principle, a fight about  policy and I think that  would bring a lot more people back because it becomes relevent again."
Simpson says he got a call from Carole James  last night and she offered him the right to make an apolgy "But I wasn't sure what I was being asked to apologize for,  so I declined,  and she said, so then  you're not part of my team." 
Simpson says Carole has never  reached out to him " She has never  pulled in me and said, lets have this out, what do  you need, can we agree to disagree,  what changes can we make?  At the end of the day if we can't get agreement, they would then say, you only have two options,  you either  stay with the program or  there's the door.  That's a fair process."

Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

My guess is Simpson will move to the Green party and be the first sitting Green party MLA
Im not a fan of Simpson but really he was pointing out the facts of the issues that alot of small resource based communites face.
The BC Govt both NDP and Liberal have a terrible record of revenue sharing and re investment back into the communites that provide the majority of provincial revenue..for example:Fort st James has needed a new hostpital and cant get one while millions of dollars in stumpage revenue has been taken out of that district over the years.
If your a leader and are an effective manager you have to take into account what people from the bottom up are telling you even if you dont agree with it.These people are on the front lines doing battle for you so their word and exprience counts. If you fire these people your empire will crumble one brick at a time.

Both James and Campbell need to go.


It doesn't matter to which party an MLA belongs. An open disagreement with the leader will result in getting fired on the spot.

The never ending finger pointing at the Liberal MLAs must include all the NDP MLAs who prefer not to get the boot and rather keep quiet.

If not, any criticism has zero credibility.
There are "free votes and then there are "free votes". Don't say what ya think or know.Just say what yer told and tow the party line. Political careers are not made by rockin' the boat. MPs? Instead of being called Members of Parliament they should be relabeled "Messengers of Parliament". Coming back to town and telling us what the PMO thinks about issues.
The who political system is corrupt! It does not matter who the hell the party is or who is on it. All it is now is a never ending pit sucking the life out of the people with taxes, fees and laws. We have no say! They will take all our money and will not stop taking even then. It will never get better. The next one who takes over from Campbell will be taking his/her orders from the same puppet master whose sole intent is to rape us of everything this province has to offer until nothing is left. We are truly sheep watching it unfold with no clue.
Wow! Maybe Gordo and James aren't so different after all.
Thats what happens when a politician tries to become a thoughtful and contributing member of society! Ohhhh what a system.
I have to go with the person that said,”the NDP has to get away from the political correctness crap and elect the best leader for the Party.”

I have no idea what Simpson’s plans are but he was a great forestry critic. What ever he does the voters will follow him. It was a dumb move to kick him out of Caucus.
Cheers
Municca: "The who(le) political system is corrupt! It does not matter who the hell the party is or who is on it. All it is now is a never ending pit sucking the life out of the people with taxes, fees and laws. We have no say! They will take all our money and will not stop taking even then. It will never get better."

It's called democracy and we are trying to export this to other countries who don't have it yet and don't want it!

Is that really such a good idea and why are we wasting lives and tens of billions insisting that we bless them with the above mentioned vexations?

Shouldn't we be straightening out our own messes first?
Why would Simpson go Green? He comes from the right of centre, and was thrown into the left of center by circumstance as I understand it.

Retired has it right. He is a potential leader of the NDP. James knows that and took this step at her peril. He is also potential cabinet material with the BCLiberals, but doubt that is where he will end up at the end of his term unless someone talks to him and he is given an offer he cannot refuse.

He is a very sharp individual from the occasions I have been able to see him in action in forestry discussion settings.
On the money northman!