Clear Full Forecast

Land Claims Deserve Cool Heads: One Man's Opinion

By Ben Meisner

Tuesday, May 23, 2006 03:50 AM

While the events taking place in Caledonia, Ontario are several thousand kilometers away from this province,never the less, the feelings of many residents of both regions are very similar.

Anyone who suggests the land claims are going very smoothly in this province is wearing blinders. There are many residents  who do not support the government's position perhaps their feelings are a result of the land claims issue referendum  that was held years ago.

The results are very obvious, you have a group, including government, which would like to have the matter of land claims settled for once and for all, while on the other side of the coin there is a group of citizens who say they are among the majority who voted for a different approach to the settlement.

The stand off in Caledonia got very ugly when the native bands in the area decided to blockade the highway for nearby residents.  The residents (out numbering the natives) put up their own road block with a view to preventing the natives from entering the area. Tempers are heating up and the fact that a couple of hundred Ontario police officers are standing between the two feuding groups (who are leterally arms length apart) suggest that the issue is boiling just below the surface.

We have escaped this kind of stand off in our negotiations to this point and those people from the native groups who might wish to make their points known by a blockade would do well to look at what has been taking place in Ontario.

Similarly, the people on the opposing side would also do well to remember that the land claims remain for the most part not settled in this province and until the matter is complete, cool heads must prevail.

I’m Meisner and that is one man's opinion.


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

No comment
Also no comment.
My comment is that what the natives did in Calidonia was bordering on terrorism. I saw one piece of fotage of a big 6'4" guy smoking an elderly lady in the head for her doing nothing more than he was doing in expressing their rights. Follow that up with the natives ripping up the road with a bull dozer that we all know they will not pay to repair and I have no simpathy for the native argument in that particular case.

I think the government needs to send a clear message and arrest those who were involved in the violence at this weekends confrontation. Its unacceptable to assault old ladies and get away with it simply because you are a native protester.

The native argument in Calidonia seems to be that they did not sign the land over 200+ years ago so therefor it is theirs. This argument needs to be stoped dead in its tracks. That line of arguement opens up all of Canada to confrontation. If they have a new claim than they should base it on the law and the merrits of their argument and not violence.

In that part of the country treaties were signed, unlike our part of the country, so I think there is no similarity of argument between the two seperate cases.

Here in BC our argument is over the right to keep Canada one government over one people through municipal style self government, or on the other hand the bulkinization of BC through Nisga style autonomous governments based on racism.

In Ontario the arguement is about changing a bad deal made by past native elders to get something new that will satisfy a growing population of their percieved entitlements.

Two completely different arguments IMO.