Clear Full Forecast

One Man's Opinion

By Ben Meisner

Thursday, December 14, 2006 03:59 AM

        
Forest Minister Rich Coleman says he has talked with his Federal counterpart and they both agree that providing funding for local homeowners who must remove beetle infested wood trees from their yards is just not in the cards.

The Mayors of Kamloops, Kelowna and Prince George held a news conference last week to try and pressure the Federal government into coming up with about $60 million from the promised Federal Beetle fund to do the job.

It is another example of our Mayor, who was the senior Mayor on the panel, getting his mouth in gear before his mind. Think about it Mr. Mayor, the fund is to be used to diversify the economy away from the reliance on the forests.

The big picture is this; let’s assume that the city began to foot the bill for the cutting of Pine trees infected by the beetle from private properties.

Now you take these trees down and meantime your neighbor next door who doesn’t have shelter from your pines anymore finds that his alder, spruce or what have, you blows down in the wind. Do you then pay him as well out of the fund or is that home owner left waving in the breeze?

 
This kind of program does nothing to get on with the job of diversifying the economy in this region and if you talk to the experts they are saying we don’t have an endless clock ticking.

Mayor Kinsley sits on a committee that received $800,000 to begin the work of changing the region's economy. Instead of looking for the avenues to accomplish, this he idles away his time trying to get funds for what?

I’m Meisner and that’s one man’s opinion.


Previous Story - Next Story



Return to Home
NetBistro

Comments

Gosh, Ben, I can almost visualize a "treeless" city. When the trees are all gone, and the wind blows, so also go the roofs of the houses.
Was it Owl who posted people had not yet resorted to living in their unfinished basements?
I quit laughing about that one when I read your posting. It actually could happen.
Mother Nature has dealt us a no win hand this time.
We could become a "natural disaster" area.
Is there anything positive about this?
>"When the trees are all gone, and the wind blows, so also go the roofs of the houses."<

I am not a UBC/UNBC trained expert...but wouldn't planting/re-forestation solve this "treelessness" problem?

Plant a tree and mother Nature will do the rest.
The City used to provide and encourage people to plant trees on the boulevards of their home. It left those streets in our City with wind protection but also looking more attractive then those where the pratice was abandoned. Compare Pinewood sub with Pinecone and you can see the difference in appearence.

Fir are the most suseptable to blow down as their root systems are near the surface compared with a pine on which the roots go down to seek water from below. They would never blow down. There are a couple of oaks that will survive in our zone three climate that have a root system like pine and they are also a very attractive tree. In Hesse park where the City has logged all the dead pine fir that was left has already blown down by the wind of the last few days.

It would also be interesting to see how some of the newer homes in the upper price range would withstand a good blow since the thought of planting trees to enhance the neigbourhood has all but been forgotten. One can look down some backyards for an entire block and not see a tree that has been planted. And like Diplomat says, plant a tree and mother nature will do the rest.

Cheers
And, pray tell, how many years will pass while Mother nature is promoting the growth of this tree to a point where it will be of any advantage, either as a wind buffer or a shade tree?
Anyone care to determine the amount of trees which would have to be planted to replace the ones taken down?
How I shake my head at "far out" suggestions by some posters.
Too ridiculous to deserve mention at times.
I planted a may tree and a maple tree just five years ago: They were pruned as required and still they already provide enough shade in the summer for 4 guys to sit around a table and have a cool one!

Nothing ridiculous about that, in my opinion. It's up to each property owner to either plant or b*tch!

Trusted,

What you have us tree planters do? Hold our collective breath until someone comes along with a fool proof answer to the problem?

Judging from the overall comments on this site, not much would ever get done!!!

Not a hell of a lot-not by me.
Lessons in futility not my bag!
So don't hold your breath.
Wouldn't want that foul air to go to waste.
Lets put it this way trusted, your mill stone have very little to grind between them.

cheers
Better than having no millstones, and sweet nothing to grind!
All the best to cheers.