Doomed If You Do- Doomed If You Don't: One Man's Opinion
By Ben Meisner
There is one major problem in the approach that Canfor is taking in its efforts to keep the Mackenzie mill open. It is seeking across the board concessions from suppliers, workers and anyone who has dealings with that mill.
That’s okay , but the moment that door is opened and they successfully are able to wring those concessions out of a battered economy, Canfor then has the opportunity to take the whole exercise one step further and try for a grand slam from all of their mills.
If Canfor is able to get concessions from the provincial government with respect to stumpage rates from Pat Bell who would like to see that mill remain open, obtain rollbacks from the haulers, the bush contractors and other suppliers in that community as they try to protect their jobs, their homes and their families then what?
It is a catch 22, and 450 families in Mackenzie face that issue today.
Dig in and they must be prepared to re locate knowing full well that they will lose thousands of dollars in up rooting their family.
Then there is a bigger picture and that is the Social responsibility of Canfor in that region.
Canfor has the TFL and no doubt would want to sell it to the highest bidder if Canfor should decide to pull up stakes. They known that down the road Mackenzie will be the "go to" place for fibre as the beetle finishes off the forests in the lower parts of the province.
Canfor also has one very good argument, in that the mill in Mackenzie has been losing about $4 million a month.
In the end there will be some very difficult decisions to be made by the workers and citizens of that community, decisions that will affect not only their lives but a goodly portion of the forest industry in BC as well.
I’m Meisner and that’s one man’s opinion.
Previous Story - Next Story
Return to Home
Jim Pattison, Third Avenue Management, and the Bentleys, they own approx 52% of the shares.
If they set the standard for keeping the mill open by getting concessions from their suppliers, and if the suppliers cannot meet the standard then it would appear that to some degree the suppliers and workers are responsibile for the closure, and Canfor will get less bad publicity.
When this closure was first announced they indicated that this was just the beginning and that there would be further announcements, as this is a long term plan by this Company. So be prepared for more.
I understand that there is significant downsizing taking place among Canfors Management at the various mills, however this type of downsizing usually doesnt get into the press.